O'Dell's Irish Pub & Ale House

"I called yesterday and made reservations for 8-10 people for 6 pm and left my name and phone number. We all were present right before 6:00. Not only did they NOT have a table reserved, they didn’t even have room for our party and refused to open the other dining area. PLUS the girl we dealt with was rude and didn’t even apologize. So we went across the street to Joe Boccardis where we were seated immediately and were treated respectfully. I’ve always liked O’Dell’s food, but am so disgusted with the way we were treated, I don’t think I’ll ever go back."

"Great atmosphere and amazing food! We came in around 3pm for a late lunch and I just had the best Reuben that I’ve ever had!!! Our waitress was very friendly and attentive! 10/10 food and service. Do yourself a favor and stop in!"

"Super cool local neighborhood pub!!! Staff and customers were extremely warm and friendly. Beer was ice cold and made for a great evening with friends!!! Love this place and wish had one similar at home"

"Two buddies and I visited O'Dell's on a Saturday afternoon. It was a destination for us, as my friend had been there previously and said the wings were fantastic (they are!). The pub is in the heart of Eureka's Historic District. We got there around 2pm and found seats at the bar. The place is comfortable and is run by family - something I appreciate. The beer selection was decent with at least one beer to accommodate just about every type of beer palate. For me, that's Bud Select, which was perfectly cold. They have a TouchTunes jukebox, so we were able to listen to music of our choosing, another nice touch. All three of us ordered the wings and a beer. While waiting for the food, we chatted with the owner, who was hand-washing beer mugs behind the bar. He gave us a little history of the place which was pretty neat. He also gave a little insight on the kitchen and the wings, and mentioned that they have an oil filtration unit that helps keep the oil clean; they change the oil frequently to ensure the food comes out great. This attention to quality showed in the wings! The wings are ordered by the pound, and come in one of three flavors: Jack Daniels, House (hot), or Garlic Parmesan. I had the House sauce, which was delicious. Not too hot, and it had a tiny bit of sweetness; very flavorful. Definitely not the standard Franks hot sauce and butter. There is a very light breaded-like coating on the wings, which added a little crunch to them. The wings were good-sized; not huge and not small. My buddies both had the Jack wings. I tried one of those but preferred the House sauce (they did too!). Overall, the experience was great. Cold beer, excellent wings, casual atmosphere, personable staff - and good music! I'll definitely go back. Highly recommend!"

"Nice little hometown gem! My friend and I ordered an appetizer trio to split: loaded fries, fried pickles, and wings. The wings have their own deliciously unique flavor and are just right so they are crispy but moist. The loaded fries are steak fries with cheese and bacon, a classic but nothing special. The fried pickles were great dipped in ranch, I liked that they were thin & not soggy."