The Posh Pagan

"Super Rad! Pretty neat selection. I'd say 60/40 casual wear (hoodies, t-shirts)/"dressed up" gothic (dresses, corsets, blouses). I was pleasantly surprised with their sizes as I'm mid-size (18 pants, XXL/XXXL shirts + dresses) and they had a lot of stuff in my size! For larger sizes the selection seemed okay, I believe they mentioned expecting more plus size corsets in the coming months. Personally I believe that nothing was too expensive, definitely cheaper than places like hot topic, torrid, killstar, etc. which is relieving to see. The only negatives I'd say were that there weren't as much dress-ier/romantic options as I would have liked, but for some quick, everyday staples it's great. Also for those w/ sensory sensitivities there is an incense-y smell here as well as the sister store. I actually really like the smell of incense, but it may bother those who don't. However the reason I rated 5 stars: 1. ACCESSORIES GALORE. Super cute jewelry, bags, harnesses, etc. 2. Super friendly staff! I have pretty bad social anxiety and they were so chill and helpful. It was my first time purchasing a corset and they talked me through it, reassured me, and just generally made me feel a lot more comfortable. As someone who is midsize shopping for something like a corset can be kind of scary, but I sensed no judgement AT ALL. For example, I love corsets style-wise but didn't really want too much cinching. The staff checked with my comfort level multiple times AND super casually got me a larger size. I usually dread trying stuff on because of that reason, but they were so nice and encouraging!! Overall: reasonably priced, mostly casual gothic/witchy items, really cute stuff, great service. I am defo planning on returning :)"

"If you are looking for a store that has unique clothing and accessories then this is it. They have a great selection. Every time I visit they have new items available and great prices. Clothes fit and feel great. Always felt welcomed by the amazing staff. Definitely will keep shopping here."

"Recently stopped again at The Posh Pagan in historic Hamilton Ohio and once more found some really cool clothing for guys so I got a couple shirts and a pair of shorts. Very comfortable and definitely stylish for sure. I should have asked what scent of incense they had burning so I could have gotten some. I was there one time they had a weird odor that was coming from the Asian Fish store next door, but that store has since closed yay! Yet another awesome experience at Posh Pagan. Thats for all the help from your most friendly staff! See you again soon!"

"I saw this place on tiktok and was extremely excited for the plus sized options, which they did have, not many, but they did. Every clothing item that I touched, t shirts dresses, sweaters, each one felt super scratchy and very unfortable. I loved the designs, though. They were really cool and well done. When I went into the store with my partner, we both got headaches from the smell. It was intense. Candles and all. We had to leave because we couldn't handle it. We did get a free gift because we bought two t shirts that were 80 dollars..... a patch. The ladies were super nice, good customer service. Uncomfortable clothes, headache store, a lot of good designs and products, and great customer service. I will sadly not be going back."

"Loved it. Lots of unique clothing and accessories. Found some great deals. Highly recommend. Drove over two hours to get there and plan to do it again someday."