Formaggio's Pizza

"Took the family here yesterday for the first time. Got the raviolis, cheese pizza and meat pizza. No complaints from anyone. Will definitely be back. Not their fault but wish there was more seating."

"Went to Formaggio's on a recommendation from a friend. I wish he had told me earlier. This was the best pizza I have eaten...period. We had the meat lover's and it absolutely held up to its name. The pizza was made as I waited. You can taste the freshness of the ingredients. The mozzarella had a very smooth, almost buttery taste that makes it hard to put down a slice once you start to eat it. A day later, thanks to the air fryer, there is no drop off in taste. The staff is welcoming and friendly. They even asked if I wanted my pizza crispy or soft. Regardless of where you are, it is worth the drive!!! You will not be sorry."

"Hey Friends, trying another pizza joint...Formaggio's Pizza. You think authentic New York Pizza, right? The name is Italian and means cheese. Come on... Nope, it was far from a New York style pizza. The Mrs. and I ordered 8 wings dressed in garlic BBQ, garlic knots and a Buffalo Chicken Pizza. The wings weren't anything special. Frozen, thawed wings drenched, I mean drenched in some kind of sauce...I don't know what... It looked like syrup truly. The garlic knots were uncooked and no crispy. They were true dough but the amount of butter/oil was 2x's the amount of garlic. So, last but not least, the pie. The pie was cooked evenly, the dough wasn't bad. Chewy but had no flavor. The buffalo sauce was from a can, no spice. Burn my mouth please with real buffalo sauce! There was no heat...There was no blue cheese, typical mozzarella. The chicken... This was the line. Prepackaged frozen but thawed chicken pieces. They were white, maybe microwaved and added the pizza. Come on, use breaded fresh chicken pieces..spice up the blandness. We paid close to $50, I'm disappointed. I wouldn't recommend the place because I want value for what I'm paying for and decent food. Just not my cup of tea, I know NY Pizza being a former New Englander. You decide. Remember Friends, Enjoy what you eat! Peace! *** Update, I observed the owners response. I appreciate his views and feelings for his business. That's passion...Maybe, this isn't my cup of tea. That's fair and fine. I did have the leftovers today. My feelings have changed a little. The garlic knots or zeppoles were better today then yesterday. We cooked them longer. They had a good crunch and the cooked garlic brought the flavor to a different level. No sauce dripping needed. The wings were better too. Cooked a lil longer to caramelize the sauce. The pizza was definitely better. The crust had more crunch. The sauce soaked into the dough. Still not enough heat. Maybe just ask for a longer cook on all three. I wish the business the best. Maybe, it's your cup of tea. Remember Friends, enjoy what you eat! Peace!"

"Based on other reviews, I had high expectations. I ordered cheese pizza with sausage - was expecting slices of sausage as menu indicated. Got sausage crumbles instead - not the same crispness. Crust wasn’t crispy, nothing remarkable about the tomato sauce and cheese. A pizza from Papa John’s would have been very close in quality for less money. I ordered in the store and waited for best outcome in freshness. It wasn’t bad, but I can do better on my grill/pizza stone with a Publix dough and jarred sauce. Then it’s crispy and toppings are correct."

"Well on the hunt for another place for pizza… Ordered on their website said 30 minutes. Got there at that time and waited another 20. Toppings were skimpy and you cannot eat there. They do pizza only. Tried to get a salad but that is not on the menu. Wanted broccoli on my pizza and that didn’t exist either. Prices were better than other but you get what you pay for."