Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza

"I’m from Long Island and am shocked at how good this place is! I had a feeling seeing the crowds that it would be good. The regular and buffalo slices were great. Cheap and quick meal. Will be back!"

"Being from NY, it’s hard to compare it to pizza in NY. They have lots of variety and flavors. Self-order kiosks make it a lot easier and quicker. No wait time for slices. My slices weren’t as hot as I hoped but I think overall it’s a good place."

"Eddie and Sam’s NY Pizza deserves all the appreciation out there for so many reasons. First of all, every flavor we ordered was deliciously seasoned and tasty. We had the meat lovers, cheese and, the star of the evening, lasagne pizza. Also, they make them freshly baked when you order a whole pizza; so it may take a while, but it’s worth the wait. Pizzas are huge by the way! Secondly, service and logistics at the restaurant work very well. You get to the counter, order on digital kiosks and get a locator. Plain and simple. As far as ambience and vibe, it’s what you’d expect from a NY style pizza joint and everything’s clean and organized. Actually, the manager was on top of cleaning. Overall, if you’re in Tampa and looking for a different option, go ahead and get a slice or, why not, a whole pie! You won’t regret it."

"Took a trip to Tampa to visit family and came here as per the reviews on Tik Tok. Coming in at 4.1 ⭐️ Odd ball star review. I couldn't bring them to 4.2 and here's the deal... Our first time here and while the layout was appreciated, it was also confusing. They have cash register to place order for single slices and soda. They also have 'online' tablets to place your order... Ok. Then there's a video monitor showcasing their food showing if you place order online, you get 10% off. But, the discount applies to orders placed on your phone, which they considered "online". Alright, so we ordered our pizzas online and Sicilian slice and soda at cash register. The Sicilian was good though my corner slice didn't have enough of the sauce and cheese to cover it - there was about a good 1 ½" - 2" of crust. On to the largest pizza... I appreciated the obnoxious size and while it was good, there were some down sides. I found the sauce alittle sweet though it had the right amount of cheese. The dough however was alittle dense for such a large pie - this may be fine for some but it threw off the texture. We also order the Buffalo chicken, which the Mrs. said it was good. Honestly the place was busy but I left just alittle disappointed."

"Great spot for grabbing pizza, watching a game and hanging with friends. NY style pizza that tastes great! You order from kiosks. Tons of pizza options by the slice or full pie. They have apps too, including wings. Soda and water.. no bar. Dine in our take out. Recommend if you are looking for a quick meal, pizza with friends, place to hang and grab some good pizza. On street parking."