Joey's New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant

"Visited with 3 other people 1/15 2024 for lunch. Food great, service great my sister left a generous tip, my husband paid with a credit card. When the statement came in , an extra $8.00 was added onto the amount of our lunch tab. I called them on 1/23 and spoke to a girl who connected me to a man who said he would call the credit card company and call me back. Here we are Friday the 26th and no call. When I visit my sister again and she suggests lunch, this is the place I won’t go to. Beware people, keep your slips and check your statements"

"This place is my fave around here. Reminds me of home with the pizza and Stromboli. Living in Staten Island and PA most of my life, they brought NY here. Great service, great prices, and delicious food. Got the Greek salad last night and WOW. A must try if you’re a fan, they pack it with allll the goodies: so good!"

"Where do I start… the moment we sat down it took a few minutes to have our server greet us, she didn’t offer any drink specials or appetizers just asked if we were ready to order. We ordered the shrimp francese and the 14 oz ribeye with roasted potatoes and seasonal veggies. The francese was great, 6 huge shrimp on there. The garlic rolls were also good. The Cesar salad we got with our dinners could have had a little more dressing. The problem was with my ribeye dinner. First and foremost, I ordered roasted potatoes as my side and they brought out mushroom risotto. I detest mushrooms, they didn’t take my plate and redo it, so I had to shove them to the side and they brought me out a separate plate with the potatoes. Once I ate those I threw the risotto on the other plate. The red Merlot reduction wasn’t on the steak it came on the side, thank god because it was awful. The seasonal veggies were just huge pieces of zucchini, onions, peppers and a few broccoli pieces. The peppers didn’t even have all the seeds cleaned out of them. They were steamed and so bland. My friend tried the risotto and said it was mushy and awful. It took us asking another server to grab our server to get her to bring us our to-go boxes and check. Also the lighting dimmed down so bad it was hard for our eyes to adjust and made me feel sleepy and ready to leave. For $60 for two meals I’m not happy at all and won’t come back."

"I ordered the eggplant parm. Told them I wanted it crispy with not a lot of sauce. With a side of angel hair pasta and Alfredo. Okay. I got through the Greek salad. Which the romaine shouldn’t come out in sheets or rolls. I would’ve personal cut into bite size pieces for my customers. Anywho. The eggplant. It was layered in sauce. Each piece. I asked for extra crispy. Minimum sauce. Nope. I kindly asked for my bill. And okay they charged me for it. I was going to go back and get a pizza from there in the future but definitely not now."

"1st time here!! The place is super clean, love the decor. We ordered the cheese ravioli that came with garlic bread and salad. That was cooked perfectly. Also ordered a spinach calzone, the thing was humongous. Definitely getting 2 meals from that. The service was perfect. Two girls running the place on a Thursday lunch with a steady flow of business. We will be back!!"