Bay Harbour Insurance Agency, Inc.

"Bay Harbour Insurance made it simple for me to secure my new business with professional liability coverage. As a new business owner, I had many insurance questions. Bay Harbour’s knowledgeable and friendly team walked me through every step of the process and wound up providing extremely competitive rates."

"Wonderful experience from start to finish with Bay Harbour. Scott Butler did all the legwork needed to insure my home. He provided every option available and always considered our finances. When our rates went up unexpectedly, he notified us immediately and helped to shop around. He’s a valuable asset to Bay Harbour!"

"As a new customer to Bay Harbour Insurance I could not be more pleased. From the start they have been extremely attentive. Communication is huge with me and it has never been an issue when dealing with this agency. They have made themselves readily available to me through text message, phone calls, and emails. Scott Butler is an amazing broker and I can honestly say that all of my interactions with him have been great where he is always helpful and informative. He is extremely accommodating and patient, as well as knowledgeable. He worked hard to secure the best home owners insurance policy for me as I embarked on purchasing a new home. What I appreciate most is the attentive and personalized service that has been given to me since my initial outreach. I feel that I can confidently say that I would not have had such a pleasant experience had I went with a larger, commercial agency. I would highly recommend Bay Harbour Insurance Agency to anyone who is not only in search of a new insurance policy, or even looking to get something that will provide excellent coverage and at great value, but also who appreciates good, old fashioned customer service."

"I’ve been a customer of Bay Harbour Insurance for many years for my auto insurance. My recent experience with Scott Butler was was fantastic!!! He was very professional, efficient, and patient, with the hundred questions I had. Thank you Scott so much!!!"

"My family and I are new to New York and Bay Harbour Insurance was recommended by a friend when I mentioned needing to find new auto and home insurance. I am so glad I took their recommendation. We began working with Scott Butler and he has been responsive to each of our questions, patient while walking through new policies, and has guided us through every step in a caring and professional manner. Thank you, Scott, for the great service you have provided!"