Wagon Train BBQ

"Good atmosphere: nicnaks, cowboy statues and such all about, but not over crowded. Always nice servers. The food is just more miss than hit. The few times I've tried the ribs, they have a black bark, and drier than a popcorn fart (it even came wrapped in plastic wrap one time, like they were trying ANYTHING to keep the moisture in). The Brisket has decent flavor from the rub, but not very tender or smokey (could use a few more hours wrapped in butcher paper back on the smoker). The pulled pork is the best meat here, pork butt being the easiest meat to BBQ, it had a good rub, tender, but very mild smoke flavor. The chicken isn't as good as Brook's BBQ, but still a decent representation of NY style BBQ chicken. The sides are either awful or amazing. They've had sweet potato sides that are always good (never tried the fries though), potato sides in general from here are good. The Mac and cheese is bland with soggy noodles, the cornbread is dry and bland (tastes like the box mix without anything special added), but the worst side is the greens. It's like they boiled collards and celery in plain water, then tossed in the dry, burnt BBQ ends without any salt or seasoning added. Definitely don't spend $70 for the Cowboy plate! Get a pulled pork sandwich, maybe a half chicken if you don't want to drive out to Oneonta for Brook's. Also kind of annoying they always forget to put BBQ sauce on the side if you ask for it when getting take out. Unfortunately Price Chopper has better brisket, ribs, and the same corn bread for 1/8th the price."

"I ordered delivery. Delivery was prompt and above average, the food on the other hand. I ordered the Brisket sandwich, baked beans, and potato salad. The Brisket was a , flavorless rubbery sauceless mess and tasted like it was made in the oven. The baked beans were a 3, smokey but flavorless. The potato salad tasted like it was store bought. The cornbread was the best part and it was a 3.5. I wish I could give this place a negative."

"Very good BBQ food. Service was fast and polite. The restaurant has some interesting decor inside. The chicken wings were very good. The ribs are absolutely delicious. The steak was good it could have used little more seasoning on it."

"I stumbled across this place while working in the area and was amazed by some amazing barbecue. It was so good I went back the next night to try different things. The price was good and the portions were fairly large. I highly recommend it"

"Rustic little place not too far off from the thruway. The food was amazing. Everything tasted homemade. Bought a bottle of their BBQ sauce and a couple slices of their homemade cheesecake to take home with us. Only downside is that they are 2 hours from where I live. I'll definitely make a point to stop here again. Maybe even make a special trip just to eat here again!"