Colter Bay

"Colter Bay was one of the first restaurants I went to when I moved to Buffalo and they made a great first impression for this city's food/bar scene. I have been back multiple times and will be back many times in the future. The staff is always nice, I love the decorations on the wall and the food is awesome. Last time I was there I got the hot chicken sandwich (amazing) and my fiancé loves their beyond burger. They (seasonally I think) have an elk burger that is to DIE for but if they don't have that the Split rock is my go to here."

"We used to Love the food here and would go often. The atmosphere was great. They had live music, which was nice. We Loved the dog wall and even had our dog's photo put up. We brought multiple people to this restaurant and bought multiple shirts. We posted photos of the food online and tagged them. I felt like we really supported this business, but we weren't treated well here. We had the worst waitress here we've ever had. She refused to accommodate any diet restrictions. We asked to buy one of the shirts and she replied, "I don't know if we have your size". I wear a men's medium. It's not an uncommon size. She never returned with the shirts and we had to ask another waitress. The menu changed. The prices went up. We no longer go."

"Stopped in for some lunch on a Saturday afternoon. Other than all of the Miami fans (lol) it was great. Our waitress was nice and efficient, food was great and service was quick."

"This is a nice restaurant. I went here while visiting Buffalo and was satisfied with my experience. This restaurant has the theme of a mountain bar somewhere out west like in Colorado, and it has a bar, booths, and high top chairs facing the windows towards the street. The table with the high top chairs is a large piece of wood. I got a lemonade with no ice from here, which tasted good. It tasted more like natural lemonade instead of minute maid lemonade.This restaurant also had multiple strings of small white lights hanging around the walls and ceilings, which created a nice aesthetic. After I drank my lemonade, I left, satisfied with my experience. I gave this restaurant five stars because it has a nice aesthetic."

"Good vibe, tasty food, friendly service, good value. Our western family was wandering buffalo after a day looking at water falling over cliffs. Hungry after re entering the USA, we ended up here. The food was high quality, the service very friendly, and generally a good value. A satisfying bar food experience. I had the beef on weck sandwich and 5 wings, hot. Beef on weck is tasty, and I love dipping in the juice. Wings had good level of heat with nice flavor. The boy devoured his 10 wings with a messy smile. Sorry, no pic of the wings.... here's the beef on weck."