Good Fellos

"We love going to Good Fellos! The atmosphere is wonderful. We especially loved eating out on their patio. We went with our two young kids and felt comfortable. And the food is amazing! We've never gotten anything we didn't like. Highly recommend!"

"After a busy long weekend we found this perfect restaurant. The staff were amazing and the drinks even better. Devlan was great to talk to and we will definitely be back. Love the atmosphere and the staff were excellent"

"Ok. Got in late tonight, and 4 people were starving. The place we usually go to was closed. So we had to get this or McDonald's. McDonald's is straight poison. So we went here for pizza. And 42 dollars for some of the worst pizzas I've had in New york is just ridiculous. I know Sacketts harbor is a bit pricey to begin with due to the type of people it attracts. And I've paid good money for nice thick crust artesian pizza and been very satisfied. This is an outrage. This is a thin crust, not even crispy like a good NY thin crust pizza is supposed to be. So, there is no money in the dough. Asked for extra cheese, and it was the same as the pizza with no extra cheese. Nevermond that they're smaller than a damn digorno pizza. I'd pay 10 per pie tops knowing what I was getting, and I'd still be reluctant because there are way better NY pizzas with actual crispy dough and crust. So I warn anyone who is interested in getting what they pay for to stay far, far away from this place. I ate 3 slices easily. My sons both ate half the other and were instantly looking for more. And my wife actually ate all three slices. And our family always jokes because she only ever gets through one and a half tops. The service was fine. The atmosphere was a bit too pretentious for our family... but as I said, Sacketts harbor always has attracted very well-off folks. So I doubt they even know how much one of these pizzas cost because they likely didn't look at the receipt lmfao. JK, but not really. And being from the jersey NY border, yall can trust my word on pizza. I can't say which state is better, but also having training in Chicago every 12th month. I know a good deep dish. And I'm a fan of all three. And this place is just gouging without even trying to do good. I actually feel like I was robbed. Wish I had gone to pick them up rather than my son. I'd have been the jersey Guido I am and opened the box and laughed and left without giving them any of my hard earned money. And to clarify, my last name is actually Guido but my great grandfather changed to O to an E when he was running away from the mafia in Brooklyn when he had kids and decided to get out. Pics so you can see how thin the crust is and small soda for size comparison."

"Great service! Wonderful restaurant space! The food was delicious. The area too Is a nice place to visit. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Definitely worth checking out if you are in the area!"

"My friends and I decided to go to Goodfellos, after it was recommended to us by a coworker. Right when we walked into the restaurant, we were greeted by numerous friendly waitresses who wanted to know if we were being helped. Because we were a party of 8, it took a few minutes for the staff to ready the table. Upon being seated, our drink and food order were taken down and placed. Even though the restaurant is a bit pricey, I decided to try a few different items. I ordered the Smoked Duck Wonton, Pork Milanese, and the Tiramisu. All three plates were very tasty. My friends also enjoyed their meals as well. I think that this place is good if you are going on a date, or having a nice friendly or family gathering."