Athena Gyro

"We went in for lunch. The restaurant is bright and comfortable. The staff was friendly, efficient and professional. The quality of the food was wonderful. We had the Gyro and they were delicious. I have not had one in a long time and was not disappointed. I mentioned my shellfish allergy and did not have a problem. We also had desert. No complaints there. Bougatsa and Baklava - they are worth every calorie! It was an enjoyable experience and we look forward to going again. FYI- We parked on the street."

"I always love a good Greek place, so while my boyfriend and I were driving down from beacon, I started to Google search for Greek places on the way down. I happened to come across Athena Gyro and thought the pictures looked pretty good. We drove slightly back in the other direction to give it a try. We were not disappointed. The interior is so cute, clean and comfortable. Our server was great and checked on us a few times even though we were annoying and indecisive. We settled on a gyro platter with rice for me and a gyro on a pita for him. Since he's a chicken tendies kind of city boy, he got that too, just because. Everything was amazing. The portions are huge and the food is tasty not oily. The salad dressing is yummy I finished my entire side salad and could barely finish my full meal. George, the owner, is so kind and also checked on us throughout our meal. Although we're not from the area, we drive up north often and will definitely be back to share more meals and conversation with George. If you haven't eaten in here yet, please do yourself a favor and give it a shot."

"I got the spanakopita (spinach pie), Greek salad, papoutsaki (half of an eggplant stuffed) which is not veg friendly because it has ground meat, dolmades (stuffed grape leaves), mushroom barley soup and cheesecake baklava. The spinach pie was dry and felt stale, I loved the dolmades and came with a sour cream dip. The cheesecake was good but the baklava layer was so hard couldn't cut it with a knife so only ate the top. I gave away the spanakopita because it had meat which I didn't know. And the mushroom soup tastes like it's from a can. There is free parking directly behind. Overall I feel like some of the food is over priced considering it doesn't feel homemade. They give you a pack of pita bread with your order so that's nice."

"We’ve eaten in once and get take out every couple of months or so since moving to Fishkill in September 2022. Consistently delicious food and friendly service. Fair prices with generous portions. You will leave here full and with leftovers. Have yet to get dessert, but their desserts look amazing."