Salerno's Pizzeria 80 Bethany Road, Hazlet, NJ 07730

"Every pizza had this pinkish sauce. I asked the lady and said it’s grated cheese. It tasted like grated cheese melted with butter. Pizza was heavy and sweet. It was weird."

"When Salerno's first opened, it was one of the best pizzerias in the area. Now, it is hit or miss experiences. I guess it depends on who is making your order. Pizza quality fluctuates with crust being either very well done to the point in which it is burnt and crumbles to very doughy and chewy. Sauce has been very acidic the past 2 times we ordered as well. My son ordered a chicken sandwich and asked for no tomato and to add bacon. He received a roll with a fried chicken cutlet and nothing else. No lettuce, cheese, bacon, or mayo. Wasn't the first time the order was wrong, either. There are other good pizzerias in the area, but farther away. May have to give one of them a try until Salernos gets back on track. Hopefully, soon!"

"Very disappointed with recent order. Asked for well done but was not made per request. Had to bake extra at home. While waiting for the pie to crisp up we went for the mozzarella sticks and again was disappointed to see how soggy they were."

"Worst pizza I ever had burnt but still undercooked in some spots. From the first bite was a salty burnt mess. Asked employee working there for another slice and he said he don’t think it’s burnt. Then proceeds to lift up the rest of the pie saying that’s how they are. My friends plain slice was not burnt at all but my plain was. Definitely will not be back here wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone. TERRIBLE pizza and customer service. Wish I used my credit card so I could have gotten my money back was a waste of my time money and the pizza I did eat layed on my stomach. Should have went to Dunkin and gotten a bagel would’ve been way better then this mess"

"My three year old grandson isn’t feeling well today and asked for a white pizza so I picked one up a few minutes ago from Salerno’s Pizzeria. I’m a new customer for Salerno’s Pizzeria and am very impressed by their friendly atmosphere, customer service and the high quality of their pizza. It is absolutely delicious. My wife just said I made our grandson very happy with the pizza. Actually it is the folks at Salerno’s Pizzeria that did so. My family will definitely be back, again and again, as a regular customer. Thank you!!! Doug"