Sutter's Mill 214 New York 59, Suffern, NY 10901

"These Brussel sprouts were amazing!!!! So much flavor"

"We had a racket here, the place is nice we rented the extra room for about 50 people. The food was very good , the help were great. Nice bar with stocked well drinks and bottles"

"Do not pass up this local gem. Burgers are amazing, juicy, flavorful, and are chock full of quality ingredients, the perfect mixture of beef, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, perched on-top of a bun that is buttery and toasted to perfection. The fries are no longer the nostalgic steak fries Sutters is known for, rather, your fries are a rustic cut potato, lightly salted to perfection. The chicken tenders were breaded and fried, not greasy, and they were massive. The pieces of chicken you are getting when you order the tenders aren’t your average tenders, you get your moneys worth here people. Wings are massive, crispy, and slathered in teriyaki, buffalo, mango habaneros, or traditional buffalo sauce. The pulled pork nachos combine savory and tangy pulled pork with a wonderful white cheese sauce, piled high on top of house made tortilla chips. This place is HIGHLY recommended."

"'First time visiting Sutter's Mill, it's a great little find! The atmosphere is casual and fun, decorated for Halloween. The food was pretty good and the beer was frosty cold! The only thing missing is live music, that would be a nice touch! Dakota took our order, she was sweet and friendly, excellent service! Check it out, the onion rings and popping jalapeño peppers are great! The french onion soup amazing!! Definitely highly recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"

"Never noticed this place before, probably because it's on the end of a little strip mall at a busy intersection. It came up on my GPS so I tried it. Service was friendly and food was delicious. I had the French Onion Soup and a cheeseburger with cheese fries. I was completely stuffed but it was all soooo good. I had to laugh because the tagline on the menu says, "Great Food at Old Fashioned Prices" and my lunch with tip was $35! Oh well, it was delicious .... I'll share some pictures. The place was empty when I got there but then filled up before I left."