Scarsella's Restaurant

"This place is sooo good and has been for decades. Brought my father there for dinner recently and we really enjoyed the food and service. They even made us some greens, oils, etc that weren't on the menu."

"We go there for dinner every Friday evening at 5 pm, no problem for parking and no waiting. The dinning room is not that big and the table are a little too close to each other but still comfortable. We always have the Italian fish dinner (we recommend spaghetti instead the shells pasta) this fish it’s always excellent and comes with a side. Fried portobello mushrooms are also very good. The tiramisu at the end is something that you really need to try. For two adults including couple of sodas the bill is usually over $60 but the food is good and the staff friendly, we really recommend this place."

"I usually don't like to leave bad reviews for places but when the shoe fits....I Stopped in on my lunch break to try a new place. They weren't too busy but it was very small and had too many tables in such a small space. I ordered a beverage and a fish sandwich and added cheese. The sandwich does not come with fries or chips. My bill for a drink and a sandwich was $15 and some change! They have a menu that's priced like we're in New York and it's Youngstown. I did receive 2 slices of bread as an appetizer that came in an unlined plastic basket?? When I went to check it seemed as if the staff were all oblivious to any customer activity. I waited at the host stand for over 4 mins while I watched the younger girl working there play on her phone and the other guy just rambling away at the kitchen staff."

"Chicken parmesan is absolutely outstanding. My bill was only 21. 48 and it came with two pieces of chicken Parmesan!"

"Ill start by saying the staff is always friendly and welcoming. The pasta shells with sauce and meatballs are delicious! My last visit was a little strange to say the least, I ordered eggplant parm and when it was brought out right away I took a look at it and thought something doesn’t look right with this eggplant and the cheese on top of it. It almost looked like it had sit out for a day or two and then was reheated. I love eggplant so right away I knew something was off especially because it looked gray at the edges, I took one bite out of it and it tasted awful, it tasted rotten with a hint of freezer burn. I politely asked for a to go box and went on with my day but I keep thinking of how horrible that eggplant tasted. Something was definitely not right with that eggplant. I feel bad for leaving 2 stars but I can’t help thinking of that horrible taste and how someone thought it was acceptable to serve that to a customer, just looking at it you can definitely tell it looks old, zoom into the pic and look at the actual edges of the eggplant. I honestly never had eggplant taste like that before."