EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN 9 Main Street, Sussex, NJ 07461

"Drove passed this place many times. We were seated quickly. Our waitress was very pleasant and helpful. Drink orders taken quickly. Lunch portions were large. We had the Piled High Pulled Pork and onion rings, cheeseburger, and hamburger with cheese, caramelized onions, bacon and BBQ sauce. DELICIOUS!!! Definitely took leftovers home! We will be back!! A hidden gem!! Loved the local history book...thank you!!!"

"We stopped in for a meal with friends. The food was amazing, I had the prime rib and it did not disappoint at all. Cooked beautifully, and the creamed spinach was second to none. The wait staff was super friendly and on point with everything. Whenever the next time we are in Sussex again, we will definitely be stopping here again!!!"

"I really enjoyed coming here. The outside looks underwhelming but inside it's great. Really good service (I did come at a slow time) but the food was definitely fresh. Definitely get anything with their pulled pork in it."

"Fun night out. Large tables so tables of 6 are easy to seat. The service and food were good. Always a festive atmosphere. The sweet potato fries are super yum and I really enjoyed the prime rib sandwich."