Yerkey's Cottages 4456 West Lake Road, Mayville, NY 14757

"Me and my girl had a blast great place"

"This place is okay for guys who like to just fish and sleep. This place was really dirty."

"DO NOT STAY HERE!!!!! The owner is very rude and not helpful at all! He yelled at us because we used one of our two parking spots in front of our cottage to park our boat temporarily before we launched it. We stayed in cottage #7. The cottages are very small, dirty, moldy, and infested with bugs and spiders. The shower was very dirty as well. These cottages haven't been updated in literally decades. The toilets did not always work. The smell that is throughout the entire cottage is absolutely horrible as well. We ended up leaving our fishing stuff in the cottage and our boat at the docks and got a hotel down the road and slept there the rest of the week because it was so bad. You are better off spending a little more and going somewhere else. Do not waste your money here!!!!"

"Been going to Yerkey Cottages for about 15 years in May and for five day fishing trip Bob has always been nice to us these collage’s work out great for me my buddy and his train set up he has is incredible."

"Great location but that's where the good stopped. Price wasn't actually bad but for the little we saved we could've gotten much better for hardly any more. Cabins haven't been updated in years. Infested with bugs. And yes I know that you have to put up with some, but they were everywhere. Kids even ended up getting bitten while sleeping. Not sure what actually bit them. Did look for bedbugs and didn't find any. Either way not ideal. I wasn't the one who booked the cabins or maybe I would have known there wasn't any AC but it was hot and for the little we saved I would've spent the extra for it. Was really the reason we got cabins instead of just camping in the first place. Couldn't use the toilets for part of a day because they use lake water and his rigged up system failed. Honestly I could've looked past all this, besides maybe the bugs, if it wasn't for how rude the owner was. Constantly spying on us and then coming out to complain about trivial stuff. Just a generally unpleasant person. We weren't ever causing trouble or making noise. We were gone doing other activities or on the lake most of every day the week we were there. I know the price may seem tempting but spend the little bit more and get something else."