1840 Tavern

"Cori our server was awesome and made my daughter special chocolate milk. My kids rated their 10 out 10... not easy to get 3 kids to all like the same restaurant. Everything was delicious and fast service."

"The service was great! The food was ok, I had a corned beef sandwich and it was just deli sliced meat and mustard on rye, pretty plain and boring for the price. They have a good draft beer selection and parking was easy at lunch time."

"A little hidden restaurant. With food that feels like it was homemade with care. The Shepards Pie was made perfectly. I went back a few times and perhaps someone makes it differently. But the one chef who made the gravy mixture stew thickened with chunks and smooth lamb grounds mixed with the perfect mashed potatoes that felt as if clouds with accents of flavor bounce on my palate, left me desiring more to come on future days."

"My entire family loves coming to this spot! We love to sit outside, especially when they have live music. A big draw for us is there gluten free options. So many, even for dessert! And so many regular options if you’re not gluten-free, it’s pretty much evenly split. Choices for everyone, and the staff is always so lovely and the food is delicious. We have had large groups here as well and they are super accommodating. It’s always a fun time!"

"So as unfortunate as this is we went here after a wake. Our party o 18 people was not prearranged nor did we have a reservation. We got seated after a very quick 5 minute wait. We had a semi private room in the rear. And our server took our drink order pretty fast. She returned to get our orders, we started with calamari, mozzarella and tomatoes, chicken wings (both Buffalo and parmesan) and also Bavarian pretzel. We enjoyed all equally however the mozzarella was less than our normal quality. The calamari was seasoned more than we are used to but was still good. As our main dishes we ordered fresh burata ravioli (not our favorite) sause was a bit too acidity for our taste. 1840 burger was a big hit, the bacon jam was genius. We also ordered the Ale battered fish and chips, fresh fish moist tender and had great crunch. Famous corned beef sandwich was good but very lean for my taste buds. It was thinly sliced which helped with the lean meat. Beyond burger was also good. We also had the pizza the kids loved.. Some of the non drivers drank some of the draft beers and most of the girls liked the Goose island IPA beer. I must say the short notice for such a big crowd would have been overwhelming for most small restaurants to handle but we felt our server handled this amazingly well and we tipped accordingly. Thank you 1840 for making a difficult time a bit better."