Tarrytown Jewelers

"My late husband purchased a pair of $3,000 diamond studs from this shop for me just about five years ago. I even have the appraisal certificate they provided me listing them at this price. I recently went in to sell them back to the store and the sales person told me how awful the quality of diamond was and couldn’t believe it came from their shop. They paid me out $500 for the earrings. Very unhappy as the original rep I thought was a friend of mine."

"Ricki made everything super easy. It was a very refreshing experience coming from the Rolex AD. I would 100% do business with them again. Highly recommend."

"I have used Greg and his staff at Tarrytown Jewelers for Breitling watch servicing (which is fast and reasonable),Jewelry appraisal, and valuation and sizing of some of my wife’s pieces. A real straight shooter and honest businessman.Highly recommended…."

"Just purchased my first Rolex here. I was recommended by my cousin who has bought a few watches from them. Ricki was extremely professional with answering my questions. The owner Steve was extremely knowledgeable and went above & beyond with customer service. I could not be more happier with this purchase. I would highly recommend Tarrytown to anyone looking for their next watch! Purchased another watch (Batman GMT 2023) from Tarrytown jewelers last week. Not sure where the negatives reviews came from because they seem to be bots or not actual real customers. I’m taking the time to write this because buying a watch is a considerable purchase. Ricki was beyond professional with me. I was in Miami and wired the money for the watch. By 9 am the next morning the watch had arrived in perfect condition and Ricki took the time to write a personal thank you note. Went to a local Rolex AD to have the watch sized to my wrist. Great customer service from Tarrytown all around (Greg/Ricki/Steve). I will continue to work with them for the years to come."

"Absolutely exceptional buying experience from Tarrytown Jewelers. Steve is a true professional and VERY quick to reply to my emails with a detailed response and he took every call when I would call with a question. I was shopping for a Rolex YM for my 50th birthday and honestly was hesitant to make a such a large purchase online but Steve went above and beyond my expectations. Watch arrived overnight as promised, date and time accurately set to MY timezone (nice touch) and in impeccable condition. Highly recommend them for any of your jewelry/watch needs."