Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Fish Creek

"This was my second time at a Wild Tomato and my first time at this location. I personally think the pizza is overpriced and I definitely recommend the location in Sister's Bay over this one. That one is much bigger and a more fun atmosphere. This location would be nice during summer to sit outside, but I would still drive the 15 minutes more north to go to the other location."

"My friend and I visited on an afternoon in September. We had been before and enjoyed our time. This visit was not as good. We waited for an extremely long time for our food - other tables came and went. We discovered that the table next to us actually received our customized pizza - which looked awesome. Their server tried to be very quiet about it when their correct pizza was served. Our server eventually came over (after being very attentive initially, we barely saw him) and just said “sorry it’s taking so long.” We pointed out that we knew what the delay was but he didn’t acknowledge it. Oh well. Accidents happen and we weren’t in a hurry. When our pizza finally did arrive, it was a terrible sight clearly having been carelessly thrown together. Toppings clumped together, dough not fully cooked. Truly a hideous pizza not worth what they charge. We thought maybe a discount off our bill was warranted or they could have given us our appetizer on the house, but there as no attempt at service recovery. Definitely not worth the money."

"Our first stop in Door County! We ordered the Door County Cherry Salad and the Margarita Pizza. It was so good! It's a very small space. We were there in the fall, so it was too cold to sit outside. We were lucky to get the last two seats inside. They have a parking lot or there's street parking. It's across the street from the Peninsula Park entrance. Highly recommend!"

"Consistently one of my favorite spots in Door County. Have visited this location at least 30 times and everytime is amazing. The service is awesome and food always comes out fast. I recommend the cheese curds, cherry walnut salad, and any pizza. The vibes are equally as good in the winter as well. There can be a long wait sometimes, but the bar is open to chill and get drinks while waiting for a table. Always worth the wait."

"stopped in while visiting Door County! What a hidden gem! The pizza was amazing! We sat outside, the weather was great! They do have inside seating, but seems like it would be hot in there! Our server was amazing! She was friendly and helpful as first timers! We went with the onion string appetizer served with the most delicious homemade ranch dressing! Now they have a bread basket appetizer that I would have loved to try but knew we would not have room for the pizza, however after seeing it go out we will be trying it next time and maybe share a salad instead! We went with the Green and Gold pizza and added caramelized onions to it…OMG, I wish we lived closer! It was, by far, one of the best pizzas we’ve ever had! Our server asked if we’d like some Parmesan, we said sure and she brought us a cup of FRESH SHAVED Parmesan, um…YES PLEASE! So, if you are visiting Door County take the time and try it out!!! Appetizer came out quick, pizza was actually pretty quick too! Prices are more than fair being in such a touristy area! Food was delicious and reheated well too!!"