TOP 30 Amish pies in Ohio

The Amish Market, located at 6121 South Avenue in Boardman, Ohio, is a unique institution offering the best of Amish quality and goodness to the Mahoning Valley and surrounding communities. With a focus on freshness, the market features a variety of foods, baked goods, produce, and dairy products on a weekly basis. Operating on limited days, customers can expect only the finest offerings from the market. Visitors to The Amish Market can enjoy a diverse selection of vendors, each operating independently and requiring separate payments. To enhance the shopping experience, customers can sign up for the Market Loyalty Program through Tapmango, earning points, rewards, and special gifts with each visit.

Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen is a charming institution located in Middlefield, Ohio, United States. This unique establishment is a bakery, food shop, restaurant, and store all rolled into one. Known for its delicious homemade Amish specialties, Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen offers a wide variety of baked goods, jams, jellies, and other traditional Amish treats. Visitors can also enjoy a hearty meal at the on-site restaurant, where classic comfort food dishes are served in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're looking to satisfy your sweet tooth or enjoy a wholesome meal, Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen is the perfect destination for a taste of authentic Amish cuisine.

Amanda's Amish Kitchen is a charming furniture and home goods store located in Minerva, Ohio, United States. Our store offers a wide selection of handcrafted Amish furniture, including dining sets, bedroom sets, and living room furniture. In addition to furniture, we also carry a variety of home goods such as quilts, rugs, and kitchenware. Our products are made with high-quality materials and exquisite craftsmanship, ensuring that each piece is built to last. Come visit Amanda's Amish Kitchen for beautifully crafted furniture and home goods that will add warmth and charm to your home.

Located in Wilmot, Ohio, the Amish Door Restaurant has been a beloved institution for almost 50 years. Starting as a small 48-seat restaurant, it has now grown into a full village offering a range of amenities and experiences. The restaurant serves traditional comfort foods such as roast beef, broasted chicken, and homemade pies. The Inn at the Amish Door provides a peaceful retreat with modern amenities like an indoor pool and jacuzzi. The Amish Door Market offers unique gifts and a deli with fine meats and cheeses. The Milana Event Center is a versatile venue for various events. Visitors rave about the delicious food, friendly service, and cozy atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a relaxing getaway, a special meal, or a unique shopping experience, the Amish Door Restaurant has something for everyone. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in Ohio's Amish Country!

Mary's Amish Bakery is a charming bakery located in Kenton, Ohio, United States. Situated at 12813 County Road 265, this quaint establishment offers a wide variety of freshly baked goods and delicious treats. From homemade pies and cookies to fluffy breads and pastries, Mary's Amish Bakery is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. Step inside and be greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked goods and the friendly smiles of the staff. Whether you're looking for a treat for yourself or a gift for a loved one, Mary's Amish Bakery has something for everyone. Visit today and indulge in the flavors of Amish tradition.

Yoder's Bakery is a charming Amish bakery located at 16653 Ohio 31 in Kenton, Ohio. This quaint establishment offers a wide variety of freshly baked goods, including breads, pastries, pies, and cookies, all made using traditional Amish recipes and techniques. In addition to their delicious baked goods, Yoder's Bakery also offers a selection of locally sourced groceries and specialty items. Whether you're looking for a sweet treat or a unique gift, Yoder's Bakery is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings. Visit us today and experience the warm hospitality and homemade goodness that the Amish are known for.

Der Dutchman is a charming institution located at 445 Jefferson Avenue in Plain City, Ohio. This beloved bakery, food, restaurant, and store offers a taste of traditional Dutch cuisine with a modern twist. From freshly baked pastries and breads to hearty meals and delicious desserts, Der Dutchman is the perfect place to enjoy a cozy meal with family and friends. With its warm atmosphere and friendly staff, this institution is a must-visit for anyone looking for a taste of Dutch hospitality in the heart of Ohio.

Das Dutch Haus Restaurant is a charming dining establishment located in Columbiana, Ohio. Situated at 14895 South Avenue, this restaurant offers a taste of authentic Dutch cuisine in a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Known for its delicious homemade dishes, friendly service, and warm hospitality, Das Dutch Haus is a popular destination for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving traditional Dutch fare like schnitzel or poffertjes, or simply want to enjoy a hearty breakfast or lunch, this restaurant is sure to satisfy your appetite. Come experience the flavors of the Netherlands right here in Ohio at Das Dutch Haus Restaurant.

Berlin Farmstead is a charming food institution located in the heart of Berlin, Ohio. Situated at 4757 Township Road 366, this restaurant offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere for guests to enjoy delicious homemade meals. Known for their traditional Amish cuisine and fresh local ingredients, Berlin Farmstead is a popular choice for those looking to experience the flavors of the region. Whether you're craving hearty comfort food or sweet homemade desserts, this institution has something for everyone. Come and experience the warm hospitality and mouthwatering dishes that Berlin Farmstead has to offer.

Der Dutchman is a charming institution located at 4967 Walnut Street in Walnut Creek, Ohio. This beloved bakery, food, restaurant, and store offers a wide range of delicious homemade treats and traditional Dutch cuisine. From freshly baked pies and pastries to hearty meals like pot roast and fried chicken, Der Dutchman is a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it the perfect place to enjoy a meal or pick up some tasty treats to take home. Whether you're craving something sweet or savory, Der Dutchman has something for everyone to enjoy.

Located at 1108 Winesburg Street in Wilmot, Ohio, The Corner Cup is a charming cafe, food, and store institution that invites visitors to "Stay, Dine, Shop, Celebrate, and Relax" with them. With almost 50 years of heritage, The Amish Door Village has been a staple in Ohio's pastoral heartland, starting as a small 48-seat restaurant in 1977 and growing into the village it is today. The institution offers traditional comfort foods such as roast beef, broasted chicken, mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and fresh pie, as well as heart-healthy options and a daily grand buffet. The Inn at the Amish Door provides a peaceful retreat with modern amenities like an indoor pool, jacuzzi, and free Wi-Fi. The Amish Door Market offers a variety of gifts, a deli with fine meats and cheeses, and a coffee shop with warm breakfast items. The Milana Event Center is a versatile venue for various activities, accommodating 20 to 400 guests. Visitors rave about the delicious food, friendly service, and cozy atmosphere. The institution is easily accessible from major highways and offers sign-ups for specials and event announcements. Come experience the warmth and hospitality of The Corner Cup at The Amish Door Village!

Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen is a charming restaurant located in Mount Hope, Ohio, nestled along Ohio's scenic Route 241. Known for its delicious homemade Amish-style dishes, this family-owned establishment offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere for guests to enjoy a hearty meal. From traditional comfort foods like fried chicken and mashed potatoes to freshly baked pies and pastries, Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen is a popular destination for locals and tourists alike. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot to enjoy a meal with loved ones or simply craving some home-cooked goodness, Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen is the perfect place to satisfy your appetite.

Der Dutch Pantry is a charming convenience store located at 2172 Locust Street in Canal Fulton, Ohio. This quaint store offers a wide variety of Dutch and Amish-inspired foods, baked goods, and household items. Step inside and be transported to a simpler time, where quality and tradition are paramount. Whether you're looking for a delicious homemade pie, fresh produce, or unique gifts, Der Dutch Pantry has something for everyone. Come experience the warmth and hospitality of this beloved institution in the heart of Ohio.

End of the Commons General Store: A Journey Back in Time Nestled in the heart of Amish Country, the End of the Commons General Store is a treasured gem located at 8719 State Rte 534, Mesopotamia, OH 44439, United States. As Ohio's oldest operating general store, established in 1840, this historic establishment offers a delightful blend of nostalgia and quality that has been cherished for generations.

Welcome to Kuntry Bake Shop, your go-to destination for mouthwatering baked goods crafted with love and tradition. Nestled in the heart of Ohio's Amish Country, at 5515 Buckskin Road, Hicksville, Ohio, we have been delighting our community for over 20 years with authentic Amish recipes that have stood the test of time. Our bakery is renowned for its commitment to quality, using only the finest ingredients to create a variety of treats that are as delicious as they are wholesome. Whether you're craving fresh bread, pastries, or cookies, our selection is sure to satisfy your taste buds.