The Stickett Inn

"We shared the below privately with Johnny at the Inn and received no response. While we loved the area, we strongly feel our stay was not worth what we paid for. The room wasn’t well cleaned or maintained, the floors had wrappers, dust everywhere, no cover on the duvet which was stained, there is peeling paint and wallpaper. We chose to pay more to have a room with a kitchen, and there were no basics like salt pepper oil at the very least, or sponges or cutting boards beyond a melted plastic one. It seems they are also cutting corners with no garbage bags, no extra toilet paper (we ran out and took a backup from another room), not to mention the highly advertised “Malin and Goetz products” (plural) which was one bar of soap— they mention this brand everywhere. When we requested shampoo and conditioner, it was never brought to us. The “staff” is not responsive or even present, much less attentive. We were just really disappointed, if we were also cutting corners we would have chosen to stay at a cheaper place where we weren’t expecting a $275 per night value, or other places we’ve stayed where this price is reflected in the cleanliness, attentive staff, etc. We are pretty low key, I’ve never left a review like this, but for this price we strongly think the inn misses the mark and feel basically scammed."

"DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY! While the place has a kitschy theme, good intention and may seem trendy and comfortable from the pictures, it's FAR from it. We paid over $500 for 2 nights and couldn't wait to leave. Even if the room was under $100/night we would feel the same way, although paying such a high price made it sting even more. Our room had many issues...no closet or dressers for clothes, hooks were broken in the bathroom, the bathroom sink and shower drains didn't work properly, windows don't open, the room was VERY musty and we found black mold in the AC unit and on the bed pillows. DISGUSTING. Truly unsettling and an unhealthy environment. We tried using the phone to contact the owners and no one picked up and the message directed us to go to the website. This stay deserves a 100% refund to be honest. The only positive was the lovely and accommodating host at the bar/restaurant who brought a smile, great drinks and decent food."

"Johnny was awesome and picked up beautiful flowers and a balloon (last minute request) so it would make a nice surprise for our occasion. Everyone was so unbelievably polite and helpful. The room was clean, charming, and had a beautiful view. The property is awesome...they had fire wood and starter fluid outside by the fire pit and the hot tub was a great surprise. Looking forward to coming back this summer. Thanks again!!!"

"Me and my wife stayed for one night for her birthday. The owners/staff set up our room with flowers and and a happy birthday banner. Also they the had a nice setup of wine cheese and nuts that were sent from a friend of my wife. The rooms are one of a kind and extremely clean and relaxing. The hot tub out back was outstanding. We spent most of our time in the bar which is a must see even if you are not staying at the inn. Highly recommend this spot great service and very comfortable. 100% will be coming back !"

"After an already long day of set backs and exhaustion, our trailer lost a tire 3 hours into our road trip. After many phone calls with less than helpful AAA representatives, we finally got a tow for the trailer, but we stuck hours from home and even further from our destination. We called the Stickett Inn, in part because of proximity and part because of the name, and we were instantly put more at ease. We arrived and enjoyed some delicious drinks with the owners while our room was prepared. We were all in good spirits by the time we headed to bed. Accommodations were wonderful. The room was spacious with a big comfortable bed. We felt completely at home and had the most restful sleep we have had in weeks. We felt completely taken care of during our whole stay. The owners really went above and beyond and we truly appreciate it! We enjoyed our experience so much, we are planning to come back on purpose next time!"