TOP 30 Best Rare collectibles in New York

Welcome to Collectibles Galore, your premier destination for unique treasures and literary gems in North Syracuse, New York. Nestled at 615 South Main Street, our charming bookstore and collectibles shop offers an eclectic mix of items that cater to both the avid reader and the dedicated collector. Step inside to discover an extensive selection of rare and vintage books, spanning various genres and eras, perfect for book enthusiasts and casual readers alike. Our shelves are thoughtfully curated to include both timeless classics and contemporary works, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Delectable Collectables is a charming home goods store located at 95 West Main Street in Angelica, New York. This delightful shop offers a curated selection of unique and stylish items for your home, including kitchenware, decor, and gifts. Whether you're looking for a special piece to add to your collection or searching for the perfect present for a loved one, Delectable Collectables has something for everyone. Visit us today and discover the perfect addition to your home!

Chosen One Collectible Toys is a premier store located at 21 Brookvale Avenue in West Babylon, New York. We specialize in offering a wide selection of rare and unique collectible toys for enthusiasts and collectors of all ages. Our store features a diverse range of action figures, vintage toys, limited edition items, and other hard-to-find collectibles. Whether you're searching for a specific item to complete your collection or looking for a special gift, our knowledgeable staff is here to help you find the perfect toy. Visit us today and discover the magic of Chosen One Collectible Toys.

The Bullpen Sports Collectibles is a premier destination for sports enthusiasts and collectors located at 165 Madison Avenue in New York, New York. This home goods store offers a wide selection of sports memorabilia, including autographed jerseys, trading cards, and other unique collectibles. Whether you're a die-hard fan looking to add to your collection or searching for the perfect gift for a sports lover in your life, The Bullpen Sports Collectibles has something for everyone. Visit us today to browse our extensive inventory and find that special piece to showcase your love for the game.

Welcome to Grand Slam Collectibles 2, your premier destination for all things collectible in Bellport, New York! Conveniently located at 10 Farber Drive, our store is a treasure trove for enthusiasts and collectors alike. We specialize in a wide range of collectibles, from sports memorabilia and trading cards to rare toys and unique finds that cater to every passion and interest. At Grand Slam Collectibles 2, we pride ourselves on offering an extensive selection of high-quality items, ensuring that you’ll always discover something special with each visit. Our knowledgeable and friendly staff are passionate about collectibles and are always ready to assist you in finding that perfect addition to your collection or the ideal gift for a fellow enthusiast.

Welcome to Rare Book Buyer, your premier destination for acquiring and selling old and rare books, located at 1050 2nd Avenue Antique Center Gallery in Manhattan, New York. As a specialized bookstore and home goods store, we offer a unique service to collectors, historians, and bibliophiles nationwide. At Rare Book Buyer, we pride ourselves on our expertise in early printed books, manuscripts, and historical documents. Our specialty includes incunabula, pre-1800 Bibles, medieval manuscripts, books of hours, natural history books, and much more. Whether you have a single rare book or an entire library or estate, we provide immediate payment and handle all logistics, including packing and shipping.

Rare Carat, Inc is a premier jewelry store located in the heart of New York City on 20 West 47th Street. Specializing in rare and exquisite diamonds, this institution is a go-to destination for those looking for high-quality, unique pieces. With a wide selection of diamonds and jewelry to choose from, Rare Carat, Inc offers a luxurious shopping experience for customers seeking the perfect piece for any occasion. Visit their store in New York City to discover the beauty and brilliance of their stunning collection.

Rhino's Comics & Collectibles is a vibrant book store and store located at 3805 Dewey Avenue in Rochester, New York. We specialize in a wide range of comic books, collectibles, toys, and vintage items. Our establishment is always on the lookout to buy new items, so if you have any to sell, please fill out the information below and attach any pictures you might have. We will get back to you promptly with our offer. Come visit us at Rhino's Comics & Collectibles for all your comic and collectible needs!

Western New York Collectibles Inc is a store located at 102 Broad Street in Tonawanda, New York. This institution specializes in a wide range of collectible items such as vintage toys, comic books, sports memorabilia, and rare coins. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out, Western New York Collectibles Inc offers a diverse selection of unique and hard-to-find items to add to your collection. With friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, this store is the perfect destination for any collector looking to find that special piece to complete their collection. Visit Western New York Collectibles Inc today and discover the treasures waiting to be found.

City Cards & Collectibles is a charming store located at 656 Forest Avenue in New York, United States. We specialize in a wide range of cards and collectibles, perfect for avid collectors and enthusiasts alike. Our store offers a diverse selection of items, including rare and vintage cards, unique collectibles, and one-of-a-kind memorabilia. Whether you're looking to add to your collection or find a special gift, City Cards & Collectibles is the place to visit. Our friendly staff is always ready to assist you in finding the perfect addition to your collection. Visit us today and discover the treasures waiting to be found at City Cards & Collectibles.

Welcome to Back Barn Antiques and Collectibles, your premier destination for unique and timeless treasures in Hamburg, New York. Located at 7098 Boston State Road, our charming store is a haven for antique enthusiasts and collectors alike. As a dedicated home goods store, we specialize in curating an eclectic mix of vintage items, rare collectibles, and classic home furnishings that add character and charm to any space. At Back Barn Antiques and Collectibles, we believe that every piece tells a story. Our carefully selected inventory includes a diverse range of items, from elegant furniture and decorative art to nostalgic memorabilia and one-of-a-kind finds. Whether you're a seasoned collector or simply looking to add a touch of history to your home, our knowledgeable staff is here to guide you through our collection and help you discover the perfect piece.

Welcome to Orion Collectibles and Toys, your ultimate destination for unique and exciting finds in Depew, New York! Conveniently located at 5844 Transit Road, our store is a treasure trove for collectors and toy enthusiasts of all ages. We pride ourselves on offering an extensive selection of rare and sought-after collectibles, action figures, vintage toys, and the latest releases that are sure to delight every fan and hobbyist. Whether you're a seasoned collector looking for that elusive piece to complete your collection or a parent seeking the perfect gift to spark your child's imagination, Orion Collectibles and Toys has something special for everyone. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff are always on hand to assist you, providing personalized service to help you discover the perfect item that matches your interests.

Welcome to Grand Central Collectibles, your ultimate destination for unique treasures and timeless reads in the heart of Lancaster, New York. Conveniently located at 32 Central Avenue, our store is a haven for book lovers and collectors alike. At Grand Central Collectibles, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse selection of rare books, vintage comics, and cherished memorabilia. Whether you're a passionate collector searching for that elusive item or a casual reader seeking your next great adventure, our friendly and knowledgeable staff are here to help you discover something special. Step into our cozy, welcoming space and explore a world of stories and collectibles that span generations. Visit us today and find your next prized possession at Grand Central Collectibles, where every item tells a story.

Welcome to Milo Toys & Collectables, your ultimate destination for unique toys, collectibles, and more! Conveniently located at 941 Montauk Highway in the charming town of Oakdale, New York, our store is a haven for enthusiasts and collectors alike. At Milo Toys & Collectables, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse selection of high-quality toys, rare collectibles, and an extensive range of books that cater to all ages and interests. Whether you're a seasoned collector, a parent searching for the perfect gift, or a book lover eager to explore new worlds, our friendly and knowledgeable staff are here to help you find exactly what you're looking for. Come visit us and discover treasures that will delight and inspire. We look forward to welcoming you to our community of passionate collectors and book enthusiasts!

Full Circle Antiques & Collectibles is a charming home goods store located at 164 Delaware Street in Walton, New York. This unique institution offers a wide range of vintage antiques and collectibles, perfect for adding a touch of nostalgia to your home decor. From classic furniture pieces to one-of-a-kind trinkets, Full Circle Antiques & Collectibles has something for everyone. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just looking for a special gift, this store is sure to provide a delightful shopping experience. Visit us today and take a trip down memory lane at Full Circle Antiques & Collectibles.

Foxprowl Collectables is a charming book store and store located at 440 Ellicott Street in Batavia, New York. This institution is a haven for collectors and enthusiasts of all kinds, offering a wide array of unique and rare items. From vintage books and comics to antique toys and memorabilia, Foxprowl Collectables has something for everyone. Whether you're searching for a special gift or looking to add to your own collection, this is the place to find it. Come visit us today and explore the treasures waiting to be discovered at Foxprowl Collectables.

April's Finds Antiques & Collectibles is a charming home goods store located at 7895 East Main Road in Le Roy, New York. Step inside and discover a treasure trove of unique and vintage items, from antique furniture and collectibles to retro decor and one-of-a-kind knick-knacks. With a carefully curated selection of goods, you're sure to find something special to add character and charm to your home. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just looking for a special gift, April's Finds is the perfect place to explore and uncover hidden gems. Visit us today and let the hunt for that perfect piece begin!

All Things Antiques And Collectibles is a unique institution located at 2788 Dewey Avenue in Rochester, New York. This establishment is a one-stop shop for all things vintage and collectible, offering a wide range of finance options for those looking to invest in valuable items. From antique furniture and home goods to rare jewelry pieces, this store has something for every collector. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting out, All Things Antiques And Collectibles is the perfect place to find that special treasure you've been searching for. Visit us today and explore our eclectic collection of timeless pieces.

528 Collectibles is a sports card store located at 135 Birch Hill Road in Locust Valley, New York. We are open 7 days a week and offer box breaks on 3 different channels, so be sure to follow us on all platforms! We specialize in breaking down boxes of Panini, Topps, Upper Deck, and other top quality cards into individual spots based on teams, divisions, or conferences in the league. You can watch our live streams of the box breaks on YouTube, Facebook Live, and Twitch. If you are a sports fan, memorabilia collector, or card enthusiast, our box breaks are perfect for you! Join our mailing list to receive exclusive offers, discounts, coupons, and giveaways. Visit our FAQ page for answers to any questions you may have about 528 Collectibles. Don't miss out on the opportunity to be a part of the exciting world of sports card collecting with us!

Bullseye Collectibles is a premier store located at 1824 Merrick Road in Merrick, New York, offering a wide selection of unique and rare collectible items. From vintage toys and memorabilia to rare coins and trading cards, Bullseye Collectibles is a treasure trove for collectors of all kinds. With a knowledgeable staff and a passion for all things collectible, this institution is a must-visit destination for anyone looking to add to their collection or find that special one-of-a-kind item.

Welcome to Babylon Collectibles, your ultimate destination for rare and unique finds in the heart of Babylon, New York. Conveniently located at 225 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon Collectibles is more than just a bookstore; it’s a treasure trove for collectors and enthusiasts alike. Our store offers an extensive collection of books, ranging from classic literature and modern bestsellers to rare editions and out-of-print volumes. In addition to books, we specialize in a diverse array of collectibles, including comics, vintage memorabilia, and pop culture artifacts. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a curious newcomer, our knowledgeable and friendly staff are here to guide you through our eclectic selection and help you discover something truly special.

Welcome to AAN Collect, your premier destination for unique and high-quality collectibles located at 40 Kellogg Road, New Hartford, New York. As a specialty store, we pride ourselves on offering an extensive selection of rare and sought-after items that cater to collectors and enthusiasts alike. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting your journey, our knowledgeable and friendly staff are here to assist you in finding the perfect addition to your collection. At AAN Collect, we are passionate about the art of collecting and strive to provide an exceptional shopping experience for every customer. Visit us today and discover the treasures that await at AAN Collect!

Welcome to Bauman Rare Books, your premier destination for exceptional rare books and unique home goods, located at 485 Madison Avenue in the heart of Manhattan, New York. Renowned for our curated collection of rare and antiquarian books, we offer a treasure trove of literary works ranging from classic first editions to signed copies and historical manuscripts. Whether you're a seasoned collector, a literary enthusiast, or simply looking for a one-of-a-kind gift, our knowledgeable staff is dedicated to helping you discover the perfect find. In addition to our extraordinary books, we also feature a selection of exquisite home goods that complement the aesthetic of any sophisticated space. Visit us today to explore a world where literature and elegance converge, and experience the timeless allure of Bauman Rare Books.

Welcome to Royal Collectibles, your ultimate destination for all things comics and collectibles in Queens, New York! Nestled at 9601 Metropolitan Avenue, our store is a haven for comic book enthusiasts, collectors, and pop culture fans alike. Whether you're hunting for rare issues, the latest releases, or unique collectibles, Royal Collectibles is the place to be. Join us for exciting events and exclusive offers throughout the year! This May 4th, celebrate FREE COMIC BOOK DAY with us and snag your favorite comics at no cost. Check out the full lineup of available comics [here](https://www.freecomicbookday.com/Article/271476-Full-Line-Up-of-Free-Comic-Book-Day-2024-Comic-Books-Announced). While you're here, explore our Maker’s Faire right next door, featuring talented local vendors from NYC offering handmade goods like jewelry, home decor, and more. Support local artisans and your beloved comic shop simultaneously!

Welcome to Pinocchio Collectibles, your charming haven for unique and rare finds in the heart of Brooklyn! Nestled at 1814 McDonald Avenue, our bookstore and specialty shop offers an enchanting selection of books, collectibles, and memorabilia that cater to both avid collectors and casual enthusiasts alike. Step into a world where stories come to life through our carefully curated collection of vintage books, limited edition items, and beloved classics. Whether you're searching for a nostalgic piece from your childhood or a one-of-a-kind gift for a loved one, Pinocchio Collectibles is your destination for timeless treasures. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff are always on hand to guide you through our diverse offerings and help you discover something truly special. Visit us today and uncover the magic of Pinocchio Collectibles, where every item has a tale to tell.

The Greenhouse Antiques And Collectibles is a charming home goods store located at 425 North Country Road in Saint James, New York. This hidden gem is a treasure trove of unique antiques and collectibles, perfect for adding a touch of vintage charm to your home decor. From furniture and artwork to trinkets and knick-knacks, you'll find a diverse selection of one-of-a-kind items that are sure to spark joy and conversation. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just looking to add a special piece to your home, The Greenhouse Antiques And Collectibles has something for everyone. Visit us today and discover the perfect piece to complete your space!

Rare 3001 is a one-of-a-kind dining experience located at 3001 Monroe Avenue in Rochester, New York. This upscale restaurant offers a unique and diverse menu featuring rare and exotic dishes from around the world. From mouth-watering steaks to delicate seafood creations, every dish is carefully crafted to tantalize your taste buds. The elegant ambiance and attentive service make Rare 3001 the perfect destination for a special evening out or a memorable celebration. Come indulge in a culinary journey like no other at Rare 3001.

Welcome to Time Warp Toys & Collectibles, your ultimate destination for nostalgic treasures and unique finds! Conveniently located at 2860 Middle Country Road in Lake Grove, New York, our store is a haven for collectors and enthusiasts of all ages. Step into a world where the past meets the present, and explore our extensive collection of vintage toys, rare collectibles, and timeless memorabilia. At Time Warp Toys & Collectibles, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse selection of items, from classic action figures and retro games to limited-edition collectibles and pop culture memorabilia. Whether you're a dedicated collector or simply looking for a special gift, our knowledgeable and friendly staff are here to help you discover that perfect piece.

JC's Cards and Collectibles is a charming store located at 24 West Avenue in Spencerport, New York. This unique establishment is a haven for collectors and enthusiasts of all kinds, offering a wide range of cards and collectibles for every interest. From rare sports memorabilia to vintage trading cards, JC's has something for everyone. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting out, you're sure to find something special at this one-of-a-kind store. Visit JC's Cards and Collectibles today and discover the perfect addition to your collection.

Cool Beat Music and Collectibles is a vibrant store located at 2445 William Street in Cheektowaga, New York, offering a wide range of music and collectible items. From vinyl records and CDs to rare memorabilia and vintage posters, this institution is a haven for music enthusiasts and collectors alike. With a diverse selection and knowledgeable staff, Cool Beat Music and Collectibles is the perfect destination for anyone looking to add some unique and special items to their collection. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting out, this store is sure to have something that will catch your eye and spark your interest.