The Best Pizzeria reviews in Carthage, New York

Stefano's Pizzeria, located at 32620 State Route 26 in Carthage, New York, is a renowned institution known for its delicious food and exceptional service. Our menu is prepared to order and from scratch, ensuring the highest quality in every dish. Despite being a small establishment, we take great pride in our work and strive to provide the best and most efficient service to our customers. Whether you choose to dine in, pick up, or have your meal delivered, you can expect nothing but the freshest and best ingredients in every bite. Our delivery service may take up to an hour, especially during busy times, but it is well worth the wait.