The 30 Best Mouthwatering pizzas in Lancaster, New York

Muscarella's Pizzeria in Lancaster, NY is a beloved institution offering delicious pizza and Italian cuisine for both dine-in and takeout. Located at 470 Aurora Street, this family-owned restaurant prides itself on using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes to create mouthwatering dishes. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita pizza or a hearty plate of pasta, Muscarella's has something for everyone. With meal delivery and takeaway options available, it's never been easier to enjoy a taste of Italy in the heart of Lancaster, New York.

Papa's Pizza Oven is a popular restaurant located at 155 Lake Avenue in Lancaster, New York. Known for its delicious pizzas cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven, Papa's Pizza Oven offers a wide variety of toppings and crust options to satisfy every palate. In addition to pizza, the restaurant also serves a selection of appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes. With convenient meal takeaway options available, Papa's Pizza Oven is the perfect spot for a quick and tasty meal on the go. Come visit us and experience the mouthwatering flavors of our authentic Italian cuisine.

Located at 205 Central Avenue in Lancaster, New York, The Yelling Goat is a popular food and restaurant institution known for its mouthwatering burgers, award-winning Berbere wings, thin crust NYC-style pizza, farm-to-table salads, unique pastas, and delicious steak and chicken dishes. The atmosphere at The Goat is casual, fun, and comfortable, making it the perfect spot for a great meal with friends or family. With a wide selection of rotating drafts and bottled beers, premium wines, and spirits, The Yelling Goat has something for everyone. Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, The Yelling Goat is the place to be. Operating hours are Monday to Thursday from 11am to 10pm, Friday to Saturday from 11am to 11pm, and Sunday from noon to 9pm. The institution is closed on holidays. Welcome to The Goat!

Ripa's Italian Restaurant is a beloved dining destination located at 4218 Walden Avenue in Lancaster, New York. Our cozy restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy authentic Italian cuisine made with the freshest ingredients. From classic pasta dishes to mouthwatering pizzas and decadent desserts, our menu has something for everyone. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch or a special dinner, Ripa's Italian Restaurant is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings for delicious Italian fare. Come dine with us and experience the flavors of Italy right here in the United States.