Italian food recommendations in Babylon, New York

Mulberry Street Babylon is a family-owned upscale pizzeria located at 30 East Main Street in Babylon, New York. Known for its high-quality food made from the freshest ingredients, this restaurant offers a variety of delicious dishes such as Caprese salad, pepperoni and cheese flatbread pizza, penne alla vodka, and chicken parm. The friendly service and welcoming atmosphere make it a great spot for a special night out or a casual meal. Customers can order directly from the restaurant or through DoorDash or Uber Eats. Reservations are recommended to secure a table at this hidden gem in Babylon Village. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a full dining experience, Mulberry Street Babylon is a must-visit destination for anyone in the area.

Cafe Gio, located at 761 Sunrise Highway in West Babylon, New York, is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant established in 1994. Known for its casual and friendly atmosphere, Cafe Gio offers a wide selection of Italian cuisine that is sure to please everyone in your group. From seafood linguine to stuffed artichokes, the menu is filled with delicious options. The restaurant also offers daily specials and chef's creations, so be sure to ask the staff for recommendations. Whether you're looking to dine in or host a special event, Cafe Gio is the perfect place. The restaurant provides excellent service and a fun ambiance, making it a popular choice for locals and visitors alike. With free parking and local delivery available, Cafe Gio ensures a convenient and enjoyable dining experience for all guests. Make a reservation today and experience the delicious food and welcoming atmosphere at Cafe Gio.

Welcome to The James, an exceptional dining destination located in the heart of Babylon, New York, at the historic Babylon Carriage House. Nestled at 21 Fire Island Avenue, our restaurant promises a multi-level dining experience that captivates with its semi-open kitchen, stunning bar, and magnificent outdoor patio. Every detail at The James has been meticulously curated to craft a unique and extraordinary space where every visit is unforgettable. Our Executive Chef has masterfully crafted a diverse and exciting menu that is sure to delight every palate. We pride ourselves on sourcing the finest ingredients to create dishes that tantalize taste buds and leave a lasting impression. Our menu features a wide range of options, including appetizers, salads, fresh raw bar offerings, fresh pastas, wild-caught seafood, and prime dry-aged steaks, ensuring there is something for everyone.