TOP 10 Italian coffee in Sayville, New York

Welcome to Poppa Mia's Italian Ice House, your go-to destination for a delightful taste of Italy right in the heart of West Sayville, New York. Conveniently located at 469 Main Street, our charming establishment is more than just a cafe—it's a celebration of authentic Italian flavors and a gathering spot for the community. At Poppa Mia's, we pride ourselves on offering a wide range of delectable treats, from our signature Italian ice and creamy gelato to freshly brewed coffee and mouthwatering pastries. Whether you're looking to enjoy a leisurely afternoon with friends or grab a quick bite on the go, our welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make every visit a memorable experience.

Welcome to Pines Pizza, your local pizza and take-away haven located at 36 Fire Island Boulevard, Sayville, New York. Nestled in the heart of the community, our restaurant boasts a charming deck that overlooks and opens directly onto Fire Island Boulevard, offering a delightful dining experience with every visit. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pizza, a fresh salad, or a convenient Grab•n•Go meal, we've got you covered. Plus, enjoy our all-day coffee service to keep you energized throughout your day. Open from early April to late September, Pines Pizza is your go-to spot for delicious food and warm hospitality. Easily accessible via Colonial Transportation, Long Island R.R., Sayville Ferry Service, MacArthur Airport, and Blade SeaPlane, we make dining out a breeze. Come join us and savor the flavors of the season!