The 30 Best Freshly baked cookies in Port Jefferson, New York

Welcome to Magic Cookies, your go-to destination for delightful baked goods in the heart of Port Jefferson, New York. Located at 24 Jefferson Landing Circle, our charming bakery is renowned for crafting irresistibly delicious cookies and a variety of other sweet treats that will enchant your taste buds. At Magic Cookies, we take pride in using high-quality ingredients and traditional baking techniques to ensure every bite is a magical experience. Whether you're in the mood for classic chocolate chip cookies, indulgent brownies, or seasonal specialties, our friendly staff is here to help you find the perfect treat. Visit us today and discover why Magic Cookies is a beloved local gem in the community. We look forward to welcoming you and sharing a little bit of magic with every cookie!

Welcome to Ralph's of Port Jeff, your go-to destination for delightful treats and a warm, friendly atmosphere in the heart of Port Jefferson! Conveniently located at 112 Main Street, our charming store is dedicated to providing a wide array of delicious food options that cater to every taste and occasion. Whether you're in the mood for a quick snack, a hearty meal, or a sweet indulgence, Ralph's offers a diverse menu that promises to satisfy your cravings. Our commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional service ensures that every visit is a memorable experience. Stop by today and discover why Ralph's of Port Jeff is a beloved local favorite in the community. We look forward to serving you!

Sweet 'n' Savory is a charming cafe and restaurant located in the heart of Port Jefferson, New York. Our cozy establishment at 18 Chandler Square offers a wide variety of delicious food options, perfect for dining in or taking away. From sweet treats like freshly baked pastries and decadent desserts to savory dishes like sandwiches, salads, and hot meals, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Our store also offers a selection of gourmet snacks and beverages for those on the go. Come visit us at Sweet 'n' Savory for a delightful dining experience in a warm and inviting atmosphere.

Welcome to your local Subway® Restaurant in Port Jefferson Station, New York, where we bring you a delicious array of bold flavors and classic favorites every day. Conveniently located at New York 112, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776, our restaurant is your go-to spot for fresh, customizable meals that cater to your taste and dietary preferences. At Subway®, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that includes our famous Footlongs, 6” sandwiches, wraps, and salads. With an assortment of fresh veggies, protein choices, and freshly baked bread, you can Make it What You Want®—whether it's a hearty sandwich, a light wrap, or a nutritious salad. For those with specific dietary needs, select locations offer a six-inch gluten-free bread option, baked off-site to prevent cross-contamination. Please consult our Allergen Information for details on gluten-containing products.

Welcome to Sarah's Bakehouse, your go-to destination for delightful baked goods in the heart of Port Jefferson, New York. Conveniently located at 19 North Columbia Street, our charming bakery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where the aroma of freshly baked treats fills the air. At Sarah's Bakehouse, we pride ourselves on crafting an exquisite selection of pastries, breads, cakes, and cookies, all made with the finest ingredients and a touch of love. Whether you're in the mood for a classic croissant, a decadent chocolate cake, or a freshly baked loaf of artisan bread, our diverse menu has something to satisfy every craving.

Welcome to Buttercup's Dairy Store, your one-stop destination for all things delicious and convenient in Port Jefferson Station, New York. Located at 285 Boyle Road, our charming establishment combines the warmth of a traditional bakery with the ease of a modern convenience store. Whether you're craving freshly baked pastries, need to pick up everyday essentials, or are looking for unique gourmet treats, Buttercup's Dairy Store has you covered. Step inside and be greeted by the enticing aroma of our artisan breads, cakes, and cookies, all lovingly prepared with the finest ingredients. Our bakery section promises a delightful selection to satisfy any sweet tooth or savory craving. Beyond the bakery, explore our well-stocked convenience store where you can find a variety of groceries, snacks, and household necessities.