Nicoletta's Italian Cafe

"This is a wonderful little Italian restaurant on main street. You might miss it if you’re not looking closely. There are several options less than 20. The portions are very generous. They season their sauce well. Their meats are fresh and tender. They make their own sausage and meatballs and they are delicious. Get the sausage! The lasagne is gigantic and well seasoned. The tortellini is tenderly al dente as it should be. The wait staff is quick and kind. Excellent dining option for a date or for the family! Everyone took boxes home and we had will be back!!"

"The food feels like levels of Olive Garden quality, I would have given three stars because I at least like olive garden, however when it comes to the service our server has to be the worst we've experienced in Cooperstown. She was rude and dismissive and seemed like she just wanted us to leave the entire time. I dont recommend Nicoletta's for food or good service. Her attitude screamed, "Go ahead and order desert. I dare you." I won't be back here again, and presumably, the baseball team I was with won't be either."

"This is AMAZING Italian food. This food fueled me through my first marathon. So much protein in the pastas!! We got the specials. Everything was spectacular."

"Ran through the rain tonight to enjoy a dinner here! We didn’t have a reservation but were seated promptly. Isaiah was our server and did a fabulous job. I had the shrimp scampi and my husband had the pork tenderloin. Both dishes were perfect and we look forward to coming back again one day!!!"

"My friend and I decided to do the Starfield Hiking Trail, and headed to Cooperstown afterward for dinner. We quickly searched using Yelp, and found Nicoletta's. The staff was extremely friendly, professional, and the restaurant was clean with a very warm and welcoming atmosphere. It should be noted that the prices were also excellent. We started with a Bruschetta which was fantastic. It has eggplant tapenade, prosciutto, roasted red peppers, and was topped with a toasted mozzarella cheese slice. It was absolutely fantastic! We were both blown away immediately. For our entrees, my friend had the chicken marsala, which he loved, and I had the lasagna. The lasagna was perfectly cooked, it had excellent sausage (which I rarely say) that was very well made, perfectly seasoned, and had no grizzle. Inside the lasagna was also perfectly cooked and delicious beef, and the ricotta cheese was so thick and creamy that I was in heaven. For dessert we shared a strawberry cheesecake which was also very yummy. It was creamy like a heavenly cloud, and my friend rolled his eyes when I said that out loud, but then agreed with me, LOL. We will definitely be coming back here the next time we are in Cooperstown."