TOP 10 Best Church thrift shop bargains in New York

Community Presbyterian Thrift is a charming store located at 12 Nottingham Road in Malverne, New York. This institution offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, furniture, and more at affordable prices. All proceeds from purchases made at Community Presbyterian Thrift go towards supporting the local community and various charitable causes. Whether you're looking for a unique find or simply want to give back to those in need, this thrift store is the perfect place to shop with a purpose. Visit us today and see what treasures you can uncover!

Trinity Lutheran Church Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 74 Forest Avenue in Glen Cove, New York. This nonprofit institution offers a wide variety of gently used clothing, household items, and unique finds at affordable prices. All proceeds from sales go towards supporting the charitable work of Trinity Lutheran Church in the local community. Come visit us and discover hidden treasures while supporting a great cause!

Christ Episcopal Church Thrift Store, located at 65 Washington Avenue in Suffern, New York, is a store that offers a variety of gently used items at affordable prices. The store has recently reopened its Housewares section, which has been fully redesigned and beautifully decorated. In addition to housewares, the store also offers a selection of men's and women's clothing and shoes. The store is currently accepting donations of kitchenware, small appliances, cookware, pots and pans, utensils, men's clothing, and shoes. Donations can be dropped off on Tuesdays and Saturdays during the store's operating hours. It is important to note that the store does not accept furniture, hazardous materials, TVs, mattresses, pillows, toys for children under nine years of age, or weapons of any kind.

Grace's Thrift Shop, located at 10 South Broadway in Nyack, New York, is a beloved institution that has been serving the community since 1968. Founded by members of Grace Episcopal Church, Nyack, the shop is an integral part of the Church's outreach program. The shop offers a wide range of items including clothing, shoes, housewares, art, collectibles, toys and games, jewelry, and more. At Grace's Thrift Shop, cleanliness and quality are top priorities. Only items that are in good condition and suitable for resale are accepted. Donations are carefully curated to ensure that customers find great deals on unique and affordable items.

St. Luke's Thrift Shop, located at 409 Pine Street in Jamestown, New York, is a charitable store operated by St. Luke's Episcopal Church. This outreach ministry transforms donated items into funds that benefit the Jamestown community. With the help of dedicated volunteers from the parish and the community, the thrift shop donates around $25,000 annually to local organizations that support education, food assistance, and community services. The shop is open for shoppers on Wednesdays through Fridays from 10 am to 2 pm, and accepts donations on Tuesdays from 9 am to noon. Visit St. Luke's Thrift Shop to shop for a cause and support the local community.

Commack Methodist Church Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 484 Town Line Road in Commack, New York. Offering a wide array of gently used items at affordable prices, this thrift shop is run by the local Methodist church and serves as a wonderful resource for the community. From clothing and accessories to household goods and furniture, you never know what treasures you may find at this hidden gem. Stop by and support a good cause while scoring great deals on unique items.

Welcome to the Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop, your go-to destination for unique finds and great bargains in East Islip, New York. Located at 87 West Main Street, our charming thrift store offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, home goods, books, and more, all at unbeatable prices. Whether you're on the hunt for vintage treasures, everyday essentials, or one-of-a-kind collectibles, you'll find something special among our ever-changing inventory. Our friendly staff and volunteers are dedicated to providing a welcoming and enjoyable shopping experience for everyone. Plus, your purchases support the local community and the charitable initiatives of the Church of St. Mary. Visit us today and discover the hidden gems waiting for you at the Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop!

The Church on the Hill Bargain Boutique is a charming home goods store located at 167-07 35th Avenue in New York, United States. This quaint boutique offers a wide selection of affordable household items, decor, and furniture. Whether you are looking to spruce up your living space or find a unique gift, The Church on the Hill Bargain Boutique has something for everyone. Visit us today to discover hidden treasures and great deals!

Rogers House - Household Thrift Store is a community institution located at 3034 North Main Street, Peru, New York, United States. Linked with St. Alexander's Church and St. James, this store offers a variety of household items at affordable prices. Additionally, it is connected to Mother Cabrini Shrine and St. Patrick's Oratory, making it a place for pilgrimages, meditation, walks, prayer, and peace. Visitors can speak to Father Scott, Father Jay, Father Gordon, or Father Christopher Carrara for more information. The parishioners of St. Augustine's / St. Patrick's Parish Community strive to celebrate the Sacraments joyfully, serve the needs of the community with compassion, and work together with other Christian organizations. Fr. Scott can be reached for special appointments, and the store is sponsored by the Brothers and Sister of Charity Peru Cell Group. With priests in residence, Monsignor Dennis Duprey and Father Francis Flynn, Rogers House - Household Thrift Store embodies the spirit of giving back to those in need.

Grace United Methodist Church Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 684 Ridgebury Road in Slate Hill, New York. This hidden gem offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, and unique treasures at affordable prices. With a mission to serve the community and support the church's outreach programs, shopping at Grace United Methodist Church Thrift Shop is not only a great way to find bargains but also a way to give back. Whether you're looking for a new wardrobe addition or searching for the perfect gift, this thrift shop has something for everyone. Visit us today and discover the special finds waiting for you at Grace United Methodist Church Thrift Shop.

Trinity Episcopal Church Thrift Shop is a community store located at 130 Main Street in Northport, New York, United States. In addition to offering a variety of affordable items for sale, the church also hosts weekly Eucharist services on Sundays at 9:30am, which can be attended in-person or online. The thrift shop is open on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays from 11:00am to 3:00pm, offering a range of second-hand goods. The church office is open from Tuesday to Friday from 9:00am to 12:30pm. Additionally, the church hosts various events and activities, such as Lenten Soup Suppers and Reflection Talks, as well as Pickleball Saturdays in Houghton Hall. Services at Trinity Episcopal Church are available in-person and streamed live on Facebook. For more information, visit their Facebook page or contact them at (631) 261-7670.

Our Holy Redeemer Thrift is a charitable store located at 87 Pine Street in Freeport, New York, United States. As a thrift store, we offer a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, and furniture at affordable prices. All proceeds from our sales go towards supporting the mission of Our Holy Redeemer Church, helping those in need in our community. Visit us today to shop for a cause and find great bargains on quality items.

St. Vincent De Paul Thrift Store is a community-focused store located at 3028 North Main Street in Peru, New York, United States. This store is linked with St. Alexander's Church and St. James, providing a space for parishioners to shop for affordable items while supporting a good cause. The institution is also associated with Mother Cabrini Shrine and St. Patrick's Oratory, offering a place for pilgrimages, meditation, walks, prayer, and peace. Visitors can speak to Father Scott, Father Jay, Father Gordon, or Father Christopher Carrara, Vocation Director, for more information about the institution. The parishioners of St. Augustine's / St. Patrick's Parish Community aim to celebrate the Sacraments of the Church joyfully, serve the needs of the community with compassion, and work together with other Christian organizations.

The Church Attic Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 47 Broadway in Amityville, New York. This hidden gem offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, books, and more at affordable prices. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, shopping at the Church Attic Thrift Shop is not only a great way to find unique treasures, but also to support the local community. Whether you're looking for a new outfit, a special gift, or just browsing for a bargain, this thrift shop is sure to have something for everyone. Visit us today and see what treasures you can find!

The Pawling United Methodist Church Thrift Store is a charming store located at 2 Dutcher Avenue in Pawling, New York. This community-driven institution offers a wide variety of gently used items including clothing, household goods, and unique treasures. Visitors can shop for affordable items while supporting the church's mission to give back to the local community. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, the Pawling United Methodist Church Thrift Store is a must-visit destination for bargain hunters and those looking to support a good cause.

Blessed Sacrament Church Thrift Store is a charitable institution located at 607 Central Avenue in Albany, New York. This store offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, and furniture at affordable prices. All proceeds from sales go towards supporting the mission and programs of Blessed Sacrament Church. Shop at this thrift store to find great deals and support a worthy cause in the community.

Thrift Shop United Church is a charitable store located at 25 Orchard Street in Middletown, New York. Run by the United Church, this institution offers a wide variety of gently used items such as clothing, household goods, books, and more at affordable prices. All proceeds from sales go towards supporting the church's community outreach programs and initiatives. By shopping at Thrift Shop United Church, customers not only find great deals but also contribute to a good cause. Visit us today and discover hidden treasures while giving back to the local community.

St. Patrick's Church Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 240 11th Street in Verplanck, New York, United States. This community-focused institution offers a wide variety of affordable clothing, household items, and unique treasures. With a mission to serve the local community, St. Patrick's Church Thrift Shop provides a welcoming and inclusive shopping experience for all. Whether you're looking for a new outfit, a special gift, or just browsing for bargains, this thrift shop is a must-visit destination. Visit us today and support a good cause while finding great deals!

Kids Korner Consignment is a charming store located at 67 Church Street in Granville, New York. We specialize in offering high-quality children's clothing, toys, and gear at affordable prices. Our inventory is constantly changing as we accept gently used items on consignment, making it a treasure trove for parents looking to save money on their children's essentials. Whether you're looking for stylish outfits, educational toys, or must-have baby gear, Kids Korner Consignment is the perfect place to find great deals on all things kids. Visit us today and discover the hidden gems waiting for you at our store.