TOP 10 Cake orders in Sayville, New York

Welcome to Poppa Mia's Italian Ice House, your go-to destination for a delightful taste of Italy right in the heart of West Sayville, New York. Conveniently located at 469 Main Street, our charming establishment is more than just a cafe—it's a celebration of authentic Italian flavors and a gathering spot for the community. At Poppa Mia's, we pride ourselves on offering a wide range of delectable treats, from our signature Italian ice and creamy gelato to freshly brewed coffee and mouthwatering pastries. Whether you're looking to enjoy a leisurely afternoon with friends or grab a quick bite on the go, our welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make every visit a memorable experience.

Welcome to Dunkin' at 165 Main Street, Sayville, New York! Nestled in the heart of Sayville, our location offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for a quick coffee run or a leisurely catch-up with friends. As a beloved bakery and cafe, we pride ourselves on serving an extensive menu that includes freshly brewed coffee, delicious donuts, and a variety of baked goods that are sure to satisfy your cravings. Whether you're looking for a hearty breakfast to kickstart your day, a mid-afternoon pick-me-up, or a convenient meal takeaway, Dunkin' has you covered. Our restaurant and store offer an array of tasty options, from savory sandwiches and wraps to sweet treats and refreshing beverages. We are committed to providing high-quality food and exceptional service to all our guests.

Welcome to Fritzsche's Bakery, your go-to destination for delightful baked goods in the heart of Sayville, New York. Conveniently located at 56 Main Street, our charming bakery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where the aroma of freshly baked treats greets you as you walk through the door. At Fritzsche's Bakery, we pride ourselves on crafting an array of delicious pastries, breads, and desserts using only the finest ingredients. Whether you're looking for a morning pick-me-up, a sweet treat for a special occasion, or a savory snack to enjoy on the go, our selection is sure to satisfy every craving.

Welcome to Audrey's Fine Baked Goods, your go-to destination for delightful and freshly baked treats in the heart of West Sayville, New York. Conveniently located at 229 Montauk Highway, our charming bakery is dedicated to bringing you an exquisite selection of artisanal baked goods crafted with love and the finest ingredients. At Audrey's, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse array of delicious options to satisfy every palate. From our decadent cakes and pastries to our perfectly baked breads and cookies, each item is a testament to our commitment to quality and taste. Whether you're stopping by for a morning pastry, an afternoon pick-me-up, or a special celebration cake, you'll find something to love at our store.