The 30 Best Beloved local eatery in New York City, New York

Local Pizza is a cozy restaurant located at 4499 New York 17B in Callicoon, New York. This popular eatery offers a wide variety of delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, Local Pizza also serves a selection of salads, appetizers, and desserts. Whether you're dining in or taking out, you're sure to enjoy the warm and welcoming atmosphere at Local Pizza. Come and taste the flavors of New York at this beloved local institution.

Henning's Local, located at 6 Old County Road in Cochecton Center, New York, has been a beloved food institution for the past twelve years. Unfortunately, due to a change in ownership and excessive rent increases, the restaurant had to close its doors on February 4, 2023. The restaurant has served thousands of guests over the years, offering a unique dining experience for special occasions and everyday meals. Executive Chef Henning Nordanger, originally from Norway, has brought his culinary expertise to the Catskills region, creating a menu that highlights local vendors and farm-to-table ingredients. While Henning's Local may be closing, Chef Henning is focusing on his next chapter at Julia's Local and his farm in Round Top. The restaurant has received accolades from publications such as Bon Appétit, The New York Times, and Food & Wine, showcasing its reputation as a must-visit dining destination in the Catskills. Local recommendations for other attractions in the area, such as The Arnold House and Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, are also provided for visitors looking to explore the region further. Henning's Local has left a lasting legacy in the community, and Chef Henning's dedication to showcasing the best of the Catskills region will be missed by all who have had the pleasure of dining at his restaurant.

New Munson Diner is a charming and cozy restaurant located at 12 Lake Street in Liberty, New York. Known for its delicious comfort food and friendly service, this diner is a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. The menu offers a variety of classic diner dishes, including hearty breakfast options, juicy burgers, and mouthwatering sandwiches. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely meal with friends and family, New Munson Diner is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings. Come in and enjoy a taste of Americana at this beloved neighborhood eatery.

City Cafe is a charming eatery located at 35 West 43rd Street in the heart of New York City. This bustling cafe offers a wide range of delicious food options, from breakfast favorites to hearty lunch and dinner choices. With a focus on fresh ingredients and flavorful dishes, City Cafe is the perfect spot for a quick meal on the go or a leisurely sit-down dining experience. In addition to its cozy dining area, City Cafe also offers convenient meal delivery services for those looking to enjoy their tasty offerings from the comfort of their own home. Whether you're in the mood for a warm cup of coffee, a satisfying sandwich, or a decadent dessert, City Cafe has something to satisfy every craving. Come visit us today and experience the delicious flavors of this beloved New York institution.

The Local Bakery & Diner is a charming eatery located at 24 Church Street in the heart of Alexandria Bay, New York. This cozy establishment offers a delightful combination of freshly baked goods and hearty diner fare, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. From delicious pastries and breads to classic American comfort food dishes, there is something for everyone to enjoy at The Local Bakery & Diner. Stop by for a tasty meal or grab a treat to-go from this beloved neighborhood institution.

Hometown Eatery is a charming restaurant located at 10366 Railroad Avenue in North Rose, New York. Founded by Colleen and Tony in 2019, this eatery has quickly become a beloved spot in the community. Originally starting as a waitress in 2017, Colleen and Tony decided to take over the business when the previous owner sold it. With the support of friends, family, and the local community, they have turned Hometown Eatery into a thriving establishment. At Hometown Eatery, we offer delicious weekly lunch and dinner specials from Wednesday to Saturday, which can be found on our specials page. In addition to our regular menu, we also provide catering services for events. Whether you're looking for a cozy meal with friends or planning a special occasion, Hometown Eatery is the perfect place to enjoy tasty food and warm hospitality. Visit us at 10366 Railroad Avenue in North Rose, New York 14516, United States.

49 Coffee House and Eatery is a charming cafe and food store located in the heart of Arcade, New York. Situated at 277 Main Street, this cozy establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere where customers can enjoy a variety of delicious coffee drinks, freshly baked pastries, and flavorful meals. Whether you're looking for a quick caffeine fix or a leisurely meal with friends, 49 Coffee House and Eatery is the perfect spot to relax and indulge in some tasty treats. Visit us today and experience the warm hospitality and delectable offerings that make us a beloved local favorite.

Located in the heart of Cuba, New York, The Perfect Blend Coffeehouse & Eatery is a beloved cafe and restaurant that has been serving the community since 2014. Situated at 14 West Main Street, our cozy establishment offers a wide range of breakfast and lunch options, along with delectable sweet treats. Whether you're looking for a quick coffee on your way to work, a leisurely lunch with friends, or a relaxing spot to catch up on emails, The Perfect Blend is the perfect place to unwind. Our menu features a variety of hot, iced, and frozen drinks, as well as savory options like panini sandwiches, wraps, and soups. We also cater to dietary restrictions with gluten-free and low-carb choices.

Henry's Local is a cozy and inviting cafe located at 570 Henry Street in the heart of New York City. Serving up delicious food and drinks, this local institution is a favorite spot for both locals and visitors alike. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Henry's Local is the perfect place to grab a bite to eat or enjoy a cup of coffee with friends. Whether you're looking for a quick snack or a leisurely meal, you'll find something to satisfy your cravings at Henry's Local. So come on in and see what all the buzz is about at this beloved neighborhood cafe.

The New Rochelle Diner is a beloved eatery located at 850 Main Street in New Rochelle, New York. This classic American diner offers a wide range of delicious comfort foods, from hearty breakfast options to juicy burgers and sandwiches. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving a stack of fluffy pancakes or a satisfying plate of meatloaf, the New Rochelle Diner has something for everyone. Come in and enjoy a taste of classic diner fare in the heart of New Rochelle.

Sergio's Pizza & Gourmet Eatery is a beloved institution located at 4803 Ditmars Boulevard in New York, United States. They specialize in delicious food and meal delivery services, offering a wide variety of options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. From their mouthwatering thin crust pizzas topped with fresh ingredients like mozzarella and basil to their savory sandwiches and salads, Sergio's has something for everyone. Their menu also features tasty appetizers like garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and crispy onion rings. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Italian dish like chicken parmigiana or a hearty sandwich piled high with meats and cheeses, Sergio's has you covered. With a focus on quality ingredients and excellent customer service, Sergio's Pizza & Gourmet Eatery is a go-to spot for delicious meals in Astoria. Stop by today and experience the flavors that make Sergio's a local favorite.

All American Hamburger Drive In is a classic American fast food joint located in Massapequa, New York. Situated at 4286 Merrick Road, this institution is a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike to indulge in delicious, no-frills burgers, fries, and milkshakes. The drive-in style service adds a touch of nostalgia to the dining experience, making it a fun and unique place to grab a quick bite to eat. With its friendly staff and mouthwatering menu, All American Hamburger Drive In is a must-visit destination for anyone craving a taste of traditional American fare.

New Great Wall Buffet is a popular Chinese restaurant located at 1145 East Union Street in Newark, New York. This restaurant offers a wide variety of delicious dishes, including traditional Chinese cuisine and American favorites. The buffet style dining experience allows customers to sample a little bit of everything, making it perfect for families and groups. The restaurant's casual and welcoming atmosphere, along with its friendly staff, make it a great choice for a casual meal or special occasion. Whether you're craving sweet and sour chicken, lo mein, or sushi, New Great Wall Buffet has something for everyone. Come enjoy a satisfying meal at this beloved local eatery.

New China King is a popular Chinese restaurant located at 524 Genesee Street in Chittenango, New York. This establishment offers a wide variety of traditional Chinese dishes, ranging from flavorful stir-fries to mouthwatering noodle dishes. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, New China King is the perfect spot for a delicious and satisfying meal. Whether you're dining in or ordering takeout, you can always count on fresh ingredients and top-notch service at this beloved local eatery.

Welcome to Diem Eatery, a charming and vibrant culinary destination located at 79 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201. Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Diem Eatery offers a delightful fusion of cafe, restaurant, and food store experiences, catering to both local residents and visitors alike. Step into our cozy and inviting space, where the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and the scent of delicious, home-cooked meals greet you at the door. Our menu is thoughtfully crafted with a diverse selection of dishes that celebrate the rich flavors and unique tastes from around the world. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a light and healthy lunch, or a decadent dinner, Diem Eatery has something to satisfy every craving.

Welcome to RJ's Authentic Eatery, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Syracuse, New York. Located at 812 Oak Street, our restaurant is renowned for offering a delectable fusion of flavors that cater to every palate. Whether you're in the mood for savory meats, crispy pizzas, or hearty breakfasts, RJ's Authentic Eatery promises a memorable dining experience. Our menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering dishes, including our signature chicken covered in gravy over rice, available in both medium and small sizes. For steak lovers, we serve a grilled marinated ribeye cut into strips, perfectly paired with white rice and drizzled with au jus. Seafood enthusiasts can indulge in our buttery grilled salmon, enhanced with RJ's secret in-house sauce or the intriguing Houdini sauce.

Welcome to Queen City Diner, your go-to destination for delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere in the heart of Endicott, New York. Nestled at 135 Washington Avenue, our beloved diner offers a delightful blend of classic American dishes and friendly service that will make you feel right at home. Whether you're craving a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a comforting dinner, our diverse menu has something for everyone. From fluffy pancakes and savory omelets to juicy burgers and fresh salads, each dish is prepared with the finest ingredients and a touch of love. Join us for a memorable dining experience where quality food and community spirit come together. We can't wait to serve you at Queen City Diner!

Welcome to DeMario's Eatery, your go-to destination for delicious dining in the heart of Chittenango, New York. Conveniently located at 249 New York 13, our charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot for a family dinner, a casual lunch with friends, or a memorable night out, DeMario's Eatery is the place to be. Our menu features a delectable array of dishes crafted from the freshest local ingredients, ensuring a delightful culinary experience for every palate. From classic comfort foods to innovative chef specials, each meal is prepared with passion and precision. Don't forget to complement your meal with one of our carefully selected wines or handcrafted cocktails.

Welcome to Rin Citi, your go-to culinary destination located at 1020 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, New York. Nestled in the heart of the vibrant Elmwood Village, Rin Citi offers a delightful dining experience that blends the rich flavors of local and international cuisines. Our restaurant prides itself on using the freshest ingredients to craft dishes that are both innovative and comforting. At Rin Citi, we believe in creating a warm and inviting atmosphere where friends, families, and food enthusiasts can gather to enjoy exceptional meals. Our diverse menu caters to a variety of tastes, featuring everything from delicious appetizers and hearty entrees to exquisite desserts. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a special celebration, Rin Citi is the perfect spot to savor unforgettable flavors.

Welcome to Parkside Drive-In, Lockport's beloved culinary gem, located at 5095 Day Road, Lockport, New York. Nestled in a charming locale, our drive-in restaurant offers a delightful dining experience that blends nostalgia with modern convenience. At Parkside Drive-In, we pride ourselves on serving a delectable variety of classic American favorites, from juicy burgers and crispy fries to creamy milkshakes and more. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite on the go or enjoying a leisurely meal with family and friends, our friendly staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service and delicious food that will keep you coming back for more. Join us for a taste of tradition and a touch of community spirit at Parkside Drive-In, where every meal is a memorable experience.

Welcome to New York Pickle Man & Deli, your go-to destination for delicious food and exceptional service in the heart of Blauvelt, New York. Conveniently located at 580 New York 303, our establishment combines the charm of a local deli with the vibrant flavors of a gourmet restaurant. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty sandwich, a refreshing salad, or our signature pickles, we have something for everyone. At New York Pickle Man & Deli, we pride ourselves on using only the freshest ingredients to craft our menu items. Our diverse selection ensures that you can find both classic deli favorites and unique culinary creations that will tantalize your taste buds. From our famous pastrami on rye to our homemade soups and sides, every dish is prepared with care and passion.

Welcome to City Streets Eatery, your go-to destination for delightful dining in Middle Island, New York. Nestled at 372 Middle Country Road, our charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for enjoying a meal with family and friends. At City Streets Eatery, we pride ourselves on serving a diverse menu that caters to all taste buds. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a delectable dinner, our carefully crafted dishes are sure to please. Our talented chefs use only the freshest ingredients to create mouthwatering meals that celebrate both classic and contemporary flavors.

Welcome to Local Burger Southampton, your ultimate destination for mouthwatering burgers and delightful shakes, nestled in the lively setting of the Southampton Golf Range. Located at 668 County Road 39, Southampton, New York, Local Burger offers more than just a meal; it's a full-fledged adventure. Whether you're perfecting your swing at the driving range, engaging in a friendly mini-golf match, or honing your batting skills in the cages, our restaurant makes dining an immersive experience. When winter arrives, our venue transforms with the addition of an ice rink, ensuring year-round fun for everyone. Local Burger Southampton is a beloved spot for families and friends, where recreational joy meets culinary excellence. Our menu features an array of delicious options, from our signature burgers and crispy chicken sandwiches to our famous Parmesan truffle fries and indulgent shakes.

Welcome to The Hub Eatery, your go-to destination for delicious dining in the heart of Utica, New York. Located at 222 Bleecker Street, The Hub Eatery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where friends and family can gather to enjoy a memorable meal. Our diverse menu features a variety of delectable dishes crafted from the freshest ingredients, catering to all tastes and preferences. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a delightful dinner, our dedicated team is here to provide exceptional service and a dining experience that will leave you coming back for more. Visit us today and discover why The Hub Eatery is a beloved local favorite!

Welcome to Brendel’s of NY Bagels and Eatery, your go-to destination for exceptional bagels and gourmet food in Farmingville, New York. Located at 1055 Portion Road, we proudly serve the Long Island community with our renowned kettlecooked bagels, which are crispy on the outside and warm and fluffy on the inside. Our dedication to quality and taste shines through in every bite, making us a beloved stop for bagel enthusiasts. At Brendel’s, we don’t just stop at bagels. We offer an extensive menu featuring the freshest and most delicious ingredients, perfect for any meal of the day. Whether you're looking for a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a delightful dinner, our offerings are crafted to please every palate.

Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen in Katonah, New York, is a charming and inviting restaurant offering authentic Italian cuisine. Located at 22 Edgemont Road, this cozy eatery is known for its delicious pizzas, pastas, and other classic Italian dishes. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Amore Pizzeria is the perfect spot for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner. Whether you're craving a traditional Margherita pizza or a hearty plate of spaghetti Bolognese, you're sure to find something to satisfy your appetite at this beloved local restaurant. Come experience the taste of Italy at Amore Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen in Katonah.

Silvio's Restaurant & Pizzeria is a charming eatery located at 628 Columbus Avenue in Thornwood, New York. This beloved establishment offers a delicious menu of authentic Italian cuisine, including freshly baked pizzas, homemade pastas, savory entrees, and delectable desserts. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot for a casual meal with family and friends. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita pizza or a hearty plate of spaghetti and meatballs, Silvio's has something for everyone. Come visit us and experience the warm hospitality and mouthwatering flavors that have made us a local favorite for years.

Constantino's of Hartsdale is a beloved institution located in the heart of Hartsdale, New York. This charming food establishment offers a unique blend of a restaurant and a store, providing customers with a one-of-a-kind dining experience. Situated at 15 East Hartsdale Avenue, Constantino's is known for its delicious homemade dishes, fresh ingredients, and warm hospitality. Whether you're looking to enjoy a cozy meal in the restaurant or pick up some gourmet ingredients to take home, Constantino's of Hartsdale has something for everyone. Come visit us and taste the flavors of Italy right here in the United States.

Talk of the Towne Deli is a charming and cozy eatery located at 138 U.S. 44 in Millerton, New York. This beloved institution is a combination of a deli, restaurant, and store, offering a wide range of delicious food options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. From freshly made sandwiches and salads to hearty soups and daily specials, there is something for everyone at Talk of the Towne Deli. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot to grab a quick bite to eat or sit down and enjoy a meal with friends and family. Don't forget to check out their selection of gourmet groceries and local products before you leave!

Coyote Flaco is a charming Mexican restaurant located at 6063 New York 82 in Stanfordville, New York. Known for its authentic flavors and warm atmosphere, Coyote Flaco offers a diverse menu of traditional Mexican dishes made with fresh ingredients and bold spices. Whether you're craving tacos, enchiladas, or homemade guacamole, Coyote Flaco has something to satisfy every palate. Come enjoy a delicious meal at this beloved local eatery and experience the taste of Mexico right here in the United States.