TOP 30 Best Authentic pizza in New York City, New York

Four Brothers Pizza Inn is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 5952 North Elm Avenue in Millerton, New York. This family-owned establishment has been serving up delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine for years, earning a reputation as a local favorite. The menu features a variety of mouthwatering pizza options, as well as pasta dishes, salads, and sandwiches. The warm and friendly atmosphere makes Four Brothers Pizza Inn the perfect spot for a casual meal with family and friends. Come in and enjoy a slice of New York's finest pizza at Four Brothers Pizza Inn!

Four Brothers Pizza Inn is a popular pizza restaurant located at 4957 New York 22 in Amenia, New York. Known for its delicious pizzas and welcoming atmosphere, Four Brothers Pizza Inn is a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. With a diverse menu offering a variety of toppings and specialty pizzas, as well as other Italian dishes, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you're dining in or taking out, Four Brothers Pizza Inn is sure to satisfy your cravings for authentic, mouthwatering pizza.

Rhinebeck Village Pizza & Restaurant is a cozy and inviting eatery located on East Market Street in the charming town of Rhinebeck, New York. Specializing in delicious pizzas and a variety of Italian dishes, this restaurant offers a diverse menu that is sure to satisfy any craving. Whether you dine in, take out, or opt for their convenient meal delivery service, you can expect fresh and flavorful food made with high-quality ingredients. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Rhinebeck Village Pizza & Restaurant is the perfect spot to enjoy a tasty meal with friends and family.

Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza is a charming restaurant located in Red Hook, New York, offering delicious wood-fired pizzas in a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Situated at 7582 North Broadway, this establishment is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area. Their pizzas are cooked to perfection in a traditional wood-fired oven, resulting in a crispy crust and mouthwatering toppings. Whether you're dining in or taking out, Salvatore's Wood Fired Pizza promises a memorable and satisfying experience for all customers. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in the heart of Red Hook!

Scali's Pizza & Pasta is a beloved local institution in Hudson, New York, offering some of the best pizza in town. In addition to their delicious pizza, they also serve up tasty pasta dishes, sandwiches, and sides. The family-owned restaurant is a favorite among locals, known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a fan of classic pizza flavors or looking to try something new, Scali's has something for everyone. With a commitment to using fresh, quality ingredients, every bite is sure to be a burst of flavor. Stop by Scali's Pizza & Pasta today and experience the magic for yourself!

Broadway Pizza is a popular eatery located in the heart of Tivoli, New York. Our restaurant offers a wide variety of delicious pizzas, made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in our wood-fired oven. In addition to our signature pizzas, we also offer a selection of salads, pasta dishes, and desserts to satisfy all cravings. Whether you dine in at our cozy restaurant or opt for our convenient meal delivery service, Broadway Pizza is sure to become your go-to spot for a satisfying and delicious meal. Visit us at 49 Broadway and experience the taste of Broadway Pizza for yourself!

Palatine Park Pizza is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 85 Palatine Park Road in Germantown, New York. Known for its delicious and authentic pizza, this establishment offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pies to satisfy every craving. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with family and friends. Whether you're looking to dine in or take out, Palatine Park Pizza is sure to leave you satisfied and coming back for more.

Il Cuore Pizza NY-82 is a cozy pizzeria located in Stanfordville, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza or a specialty pie, Il Cuore Pizza NY-82 has something for everyone. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and a convenient location on New York 82, this institution is a must-visit for any food lover in the area.

Four Brothers Pizza Inn is a popular restaurant located at 3189 New York 22 in Dover Plains, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, this family-owned establishment has been serving satisfied customers for years. With a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, Four Brothers Pizza Inn is the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with friends and family. From traditional thin crust pizzas to hearty pasta dishes, there is something on the menu for everyone to enjoy. Come visit Four Brothers Pizza Inn for a taste of authentic Italian flavors in the heart of New York.

Four Brothers Pizza Inn is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 3803 New York 9G in Rhinebeck, New York. This family-owned establishment specializes in delicious, freshly made pizzas that are perfect for sharing with loved ones. In addition to their mouth-watering pizza options, Four Brothers Pizza Inn also offers a variety of other Italian dishes, salads, and appetizers to satisfy any craving. Whether you're looking for a casual meal with friends or a family dinner, Four Brothers Pizza Inn is the perfect spot to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine in a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

Village Pizza II is a cozy and inviting restaurant located on Main Street in Catskill, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, this popular spot is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a warm and friendly atmosphere, Village Pizza II offers a wide variety of dining options, from traditional pizzas to pasta dishes and salads. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely meal with friends and family, Village Pizza II is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings. Come and experience the mouthwatering flavors and exceptional service at this charming eatery in the heart of Catskill.

Pizza Margherita Salt Point is a popular food institution located at 2517 U.S. 44 in Salt Point, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas, they offer a variety of toppings such as marinara sauce, EVOO, basil, grated cheese, fresh mozzarella, sautéed spinach, seasoned ricotta, mozzarella cheese, and more. They also serve salads, pasta dishes, and chicken entrees. The restaurant has been a Slice partner for one year and offers curbside pickup for easy takeout. Accepting credit cards, Pizza Margherita Salt Point is a convenient option for a tasty meal. Follow them on social media to stay updated on deals and offers.

Benny's Pizza is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 18 West Road in Pleasant Valley, New York. Known for their delicious and authentic pizzas, Benny's offers a wide variety of toppings and crust options to satisfy any craving. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, they also serve a selection of appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes. With friendly service and a warm atmosphere, Benny's Pizza is the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends and family. Visit them today to experience a taste of Italy right in the heart of Pleasant Valley.

Pizza Star is a popular restaurant located at 346 New York 212 in Saugerties, New York. Known for its delicious and authentic Italian-style pizzas, Pizza Star offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pizzas to satisfy every craving. Whether you're dining in or taking out, you can enjoy the fresh ingredients and mouthwatering flavors that make Pizza Star a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this restaurant is the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with family and friends. Come experience the taste of Italy at Pizza Star!

Four Brothers Pizza Inn is a cozy and inviting restaurant located in Pleasant Valley, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, this family-owned establishment has been serving up mouthwatering dishes for years. With a warm and friendly atmosphere, Four Brothers Pizza Inn is the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with friends and family. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a hearty pasta dish, you're sure to find something to satisfy your appetite at this popular eatery. Stop by 1890 U.S. 44 to experience the delicious flavors of Four Brothers Pizza Inn for yourself.

Village Pizza & Restaurant is a cozy and welcoming eatery located on Main Street in Saugerties, New York. Serving up delicious and authentic pizzas, pastas, and other Italian dishes, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and a menu full of mouth-watering options, Village Pizza & Restaurant is the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a hearty plate of spaghetti and meatballs, you're sure to find something to satisfy your appetite at this charming establishment. Come in and taste the flavors of Italy right in the heart of Saugerties.

Madison's Pizza & Catering is a popular food institution located at 17 North Avenue in Pleasant Valley, New York, United States. Specializing in delicious pizzas and catering services, Madison's offers a wide variety of mouth-watering dishes that are perfect for any occasion. Whether you're looking to dine in at the cozy restaurant or have a meal delivered to your doorstep, Madison's Pizza & Catering is the go-to spot for satisfying your cravings. With a commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional service, Madison's is sure to become your new favorite dining destination.

Pizza Express is a popular food institution located at 1520 State Route 55 in Lagrangeville, New York, United States. Known for their delicious pizzas made with San Marzano plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil, Pizza Express offers a variety of unique toppings such as broccoli rabe, fennel sausage, sun-dried tomatoes, and more. In addition to their mouth-watering pizzas, they also serve a range of salads, sandwiches, calzones, and pasta dishes. With options like grilled chicken with bacon and ranch dressing, Cajun chicken with peppers and mozzarella, and cheeseless pizza topped with fresh veggies, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Pizza Express is a favorite among locals and has been a Slice partner for 5 years, making it a trusted and beloved establishment in the community. Customers can easily order online for curbside pickup or visit one of their other locations for a delicious meal on the go. Don't miss out on trying their signature Mozzarella Pizza for a truly authentic Lagrangeville experience.

Joe Cristiano's Pizza is a beloved institution located at 1225 New York 9G in Hyde Park, New York. Specializing in delicious pizza, this restaurant offers both delivery and takeaway options for those craving a satisfying meal. With a menu filled with mouth-watering options, Joe Cristiano's Pizza is the perfect spot to satisfy your pizza cravings in the United States.

Cousin's Pizza is a popular food institution located at 1815 New York 22 in Wingdale, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas, they offer a wide variety of toppings including mushrooms, onions, peppers, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni, anchovies, lettuce, tomatoes, olives, and more. In addition to pizzas, they also serve salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes, and desserts like chocolate brownies and cheesecake. With options for dine-in, takeout, and curbside pickup, Cousin's Pizza is a convenient choice for a tasty meal. They also offer specials like pizza and wing combos, garlic knots, and Greek salads. Open from 11:00 AM to 4:00 PM, they have lunch specials like sandwiches and grilled cheese.

Bronx Pie Pizza is a popular restaurant located at 264 North Road in Poughkeepsie, New York. Specializing in delicious, authentic New York-style pizza, Bronx Pie Pizza offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pies to choose from. Whether you're dining in, ordering for delivery, or picking up a meal to go, Bronx Pie Pizza is the perfect spot for a satisfying and tasty meal. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this institution is a go-to destination for pizza lovers in the area.

Joe Cristiano's Pizza is a popular eatery located at 518 Salt Point Turnpike in Poughkeepsie, New York. This institution offers delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine for both delivery and takeout. With a cozy restaurant atmosphere and friendly staff, Joe Cristiano's Pizza is the perfect spot to enjoy a satisfying meal with friends and family. Choose from a variety of mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and other classic Italian dishes. Whether you're craving a quick bite or a full meal, Joe Cristiano's Pizza has something for everyone. Visit us today and satisfy your cravings for authentic Italian flavors!

Cousins Woodfire Pizza Cafe is a popular food establishment located on State Route 55 in Wingdale, New York. They offer a variety of delicious food options, including garlic bread, cheese sticks, French fries, sweet potato fries, crispy onion slices, salads, sandwiches, and a wide selection of mouth-watering pizzas with various toppings. Their menu also includes breakfast options such as cheese steak n eggs, pancakes, and custom pastries. Customers can enjoy their meals with a side of soda for a more satisfying experience. Cousins Woodfire Pizza Cafe has been a Slice partner since 2018, providing great pizza to the local community.

Village Pizza, located at 46 Charles Colman Boulevard in Pawling, New York, offers a wide variety of delicious food options for delivery or dine-in. Specializing in thick crust square pizzas with a variety of toppings such as mozzarella, bacon, chicken, and ranch dressing, Village Pizza also offers classic Italian dishes like pasta, chicken, and seafood. Their menu includes appetizers like fried calamari, onion rings, and garlic bread, as well as fresh salads and sandwiches. With options for both meat lovers and vegetarians, Village Pizza is sure to have something for everyone. Known for their Cheese Pizza, Village Pizza is a local favorite and a must-try for anyone in the Pawling area. Stop by or call ahead for curbside pickup to enjoy a hot and delicious meal from Village Pizza today.

Pizza Margherita is a beloved Italian restaurant located at 704 Freedom Plains Road in Poughkeepsie, New York. Specializing in authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, their signature dish is the Margherita pizza, topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil. In addition to their delicious pizzas, they also offer a variety of traditional Italian dishes such as pasta, salads, and desserts. With a cozy and inviting atmosphere, Pizza Margherita is the perfect spot for a casual meal with family and friends. Come experience a taste of Italy right in the heart of Poughkeepsie.

Gino’s Pizza & Restaurant is a beloved establishment located at 706 Main Street in Poughkeepsie, New York. Known for its authentic and fresh Italian cuisine, Gino’s offers a wide variety of homemade dishes made with high-quality ingredients such as extra virgin olive oil, balsamic vinegar, garlic, pasta, fresh tomatoes, and more. From classic Margherita Pizza to decadent Tiramisu, there is something for everyone on the menu. Whether you choose to dine in or opt for delivery, Gino’s is open seven days a week to satisfy your cravings for delicious Italian food. With a commitment to quality and flavor, Gino’s Pizza & Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone in the Poughkeepsie area looking for a taste of Italy.

TJ's Pizza is a popular dining destination located at 595 Main Street in Poughkeepsie, New York. This establishment offers a wide variety of delicious pizzas, made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. In addition to pizza, TJ's also serves a range of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and desserts. Customers can choose to dine in, take their meal to go, or have it delivered to their doorstep. With friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, TJ's Pizza is the perfect spot for a casual meal with family and friends.

Gappy's Pizza, located at 1323 New York 52 in Carmel Hamlet, New York, is a renowned institution offering authentic New York style pizza and Italian cuisine. Known for our oversized pizza slices and award-winning sauce, Gappy's is the go-to spot for locals and travelers alike. Whether you're planning a wedding, office meeting, or just looking for a delicious meal, Gappy's has you covered. Owner George Papazian opened the doors in 2002, and since then, our dedicated kitchen staff has been serving up quality food at affordable prices. From Margherita Pizza to Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Wings, and Lasagna, we offer a full menu to satisfy your cravings. Enjoy a relaxed and casual dining experience with our super-friendly staff, who will make you feel like family.

Sauro's Town Square Pizza Cafe is a family-owned and operated pizzeria and café located at 1072 New York 311, Patterson, New York. We offer a rich dining experience with a focus on using top quality, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Our friendly and welcoming staff is dedicated to making every customer feel valued and at home. At Sauro's Town Square Pizza Cafe, we offer a variety of menu items made with only the freshest ingredients, all made to order. In addition to our delicious food options, we also have a selection of handcrafted cocktails and a curated selection of local, domestic, and imported beers.

Fratello's Pizza Hopewell Junction is a popular restaurant located at 2537 New York 52 in Hopewell Junction, New York, United States. Known for their delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, Fratello's offers a wide variety of options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this institution is perfect for a casual meal with family and friends. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a hearty pasta dish, Fratello's has something for everyone. Come experience the authentic flavors and warm hospitality at Fratello's Pizza Hopewell Junction.