TOP 30 Best Historic and unique stays in Cape May, New Jersey

Lokal Hotel - Cape May is a boutique hotel located at 5 Stockton Place in Cape May, New Jersey. This micro beach resort offers eight apartment-style hotel rooms, with a mix of two-bedroom and studio layouts. Guests can enjoy a heated salt-water pool, outdoor cooking options, private outdoor areas for each room, and much more. The hotel is family-friendly and provides all the amenities needed for a comfortable stay, including beach chairs, umbrellas, games, coolers, and more. The pool is open year-round, and the hotel aims to be the first to open and last to close in Cape May each year. Commercial beach tags are provided to guests, and beach chairs and umbrellas are available at Howard Beach. The rooms feature fully stocked kitchens, luxurious linens, and complimentary beverages. Minimum stay requirements vary depending on the season. Come relax and enjoy all that Lokal Hotel - Cape May has to offer!

The Mason Cottage Bed and Breakfast, located at 623 Columbia Avenue in Cape May, New Jersey, offers a unique blend of history and modern comforts. Situated in the heart of historic downtown Cape May, this charming inn provides a peaceful retreat for guests to relax and unwind. Built in 1871, The Mason Cottage retains its Victorian charm with lofty ceilings, full-length windows, and a sweeping veranda. The innkeepers are dedicated to providing attentive and knowledgeable service to ensure a memorable stay for all guests.

The Mainstay Inn Bed and Breakfast in Cape May, New Jersey, offers a charming and cozy accommodation experience for guests looking to unwind and relax in a historic setting. Located at 635 Columbia Avenue, this quaint establishment provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with beautifully decorated rooms and gracious hospitality. Whether you're visiting for a romantic getaway or a family vacation, Mainstay Inn Bed and Breakfast is the perfect place to stay while exploring all that Cape May has to offer. With its convenient location, comfortable accommodations, and delicious breakfasts served daily, this lodging institution is sure to make your stay a memorable one.

Located at 7 Ocean Street in Cape May, New Jersey, The Inn of Cape May is a historic institution that has been welcoming guests since 1894. Originally a Colonial boarding house, it has now been transformed into a modern beachfront destination while still retaining its charming historic character. Guests can enjoy discounts on 2 & 3 night stays from March 25th to April 6th and partake in a variety of activities such as wine tasting, kite sailing, and exclusive cooking sessions with Chef Sam.

Elaine's Cape May is a modern Boutique Hotel, Restaurant, Phinney's Pub, and Patio Bar located at 513 Lafayette Street in Cape May, New Jersey. Adjacent to the Washington Street Shopping Mall with over 75 unique shops and restaurants, and just a short walking distance to the beach and promenade, Elaine's is a popular destination for both locals and visitors alike. The hotel offers comfortable accommodations with modern amenities, private off-street parking, and stylish decor in each 'Signature Nest' room. With two bars, a restaurant, and boutique shopping on site, there is always excitement at Elaine's. The culinary staff at Elaine's works hard to deliver the freshest ingredients and finest cocktail options in Cape May, making dining at Elaine's a truly enjoyable experience. Whether you're looking for a place to stay, dine, shop, or relax, Elaine's Cape May has it all.

The Cape May Vacation Rental - Holly Suite is a charming one-bedroom condominium located at 32 Jackson Street in the heart of Cape May's historic district in New Jersey, United States. Situated at the Cape May Puffin Suites, this cozy vacation rental offers a comfortable stay in one of the country's most well-preserved Victorian seaside towns. The Holly Suite is just half a block away from the beach and steps away from the Washington Street Mall with its restaurants and shops. Guests can relax on the private ocean-view roof deck, enjoy the cozy outdoor spaces, or unwind on the large front porch with comfortable seating. The suite sleeps up to 4 guests with a queen-size bed in the main bedroom and two full-size sleeper sofas in the living room and sitting room/sunroom.

The Mermaid and the Whale is a unique lodging destination located at 1077 Seashore Road in Cape May, New Jersey. This historic farmhouse offers a charming and comfortable stay for guests, with all the comforts of home provided. The beautiful expansive property surrounding the institution adds to the peaceful and relaxing atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a vacation rental, real estate agency, or travel agency services, The Mermaid and the Whale stands out as a special place to stay in Cape May.

Griscom House Cape May is a charming inn located at 905 Beach Avenue in the historic town of Cape May, New Jersey. This beautifully restored Victorian-era property offers guests a cozy and comfortable retreat just steps away from the beach. With its elegant decor, modern amenities, and personalized service, Griscom House Cape May provides a peaceful and relaxing atmosphere for visitors looking to experience the charm of this seaside town. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a weekend escape, Griscom House Cape May is the perfect destination for your next trip to the Jersey Shore.

The Cape May Vacation Rental - "Rose" Suite is a hidden gem located at 32 Jackson Street in beautiful Cape May, New Jersey. This real estate and travel agency offers a unique blend of coastal charm and modern comfort, providing the perfect seaside escape for families or couples seeking a romantic retreat. The suite features a well-appointed kitchen, cozy living area, and comfortable bedrooms, all bathed in natural light and decorated in a coastal aesthetic that pays homage to Cape May's maritime heritage. Step outside to the quaint porch and savor the fresh coastal air, or venture out to explore the historic sites, beautiful beaches, and renowned dining establishments just steps away. Book your stay at the "Rose" Suite and experience the history and charm of Cape May in a comfortable and elegant setting. With no additional booking, taxes, or reservation fees, this affordable vacation rental provides everything you need for a memorable stay in this picturesque seaside town.

729 Franklin Street in Cape May is home to a reputable real estate agency and travel agency. Whether you are looking to buy or rent a property in this charming seaside town, or seeking assistance with planning your next vacation or getaway, the professionals at this institution are here to help. Conveniently located in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey, they offer personalized service and expert advice to meet all your real estate and travel needs. Visit them today at 729 Franklin Street to start your next adventure!

Welcome to The Mission Inn, a charming and historic lodging destination nestled in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey. Located at 1117 New Jersey Avenue, our inn offers a unique and inviting escape for travelers seeking comfort and tranquility in a picturesque setting. The Mission Inn is renowned for its enchanting blend of Spanish Mission-style architecture and warm hospitality. Each of our beautifully appointed rooms is designed to provide a relaxing retreat, featuring elegant furnishings, luxurious linens, and modern amenities to ensure a comfortable stay.

The Inn at the Park is a charming lodging establishment located at 1002 Washington Street in the picturesque town of Cape May, New Jersey, United States. Situated in a historic building, this inn offers cozy and comfortable accommodations for guests looking to experience the beauty and charm of Cape May. With its convenient location near the beach, shops, and restaurants, the Inn at the Park is the perfect choice for a relaxing getaway in this seaside town. Guests can enjoy modern amenities, friendly service, and a peaceful atmosphere during their stay at this lovely inn.

The Luther Ogden Inn is a charming lodging establishment located at 815 Kearney Avenue in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This historic inn offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere for guests looking to relax and unwind in a beautiful seaside town. The inn features comfortable rooms, delicious breakfast options, and a convenient location near local attractions and the beach. Whether you are visiting Cape May for a romantic getaway or a family vacation, the Luther Ogden Inn is the perfect place to stay. Book your stay today and experience the warm hospitality and unique charm of this lovely inn.

Welcome to Virginia Hotel & Cottages, a charming and historic establishment located at 25 Jackson Street in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. Our institution offers a range of services including lodging in our cozy cottages, delicious dining options at our restaurant, a lively night club for entertainment, and a fully equipped bar for refreshing drinks. In addition, we also provide real estate services for those looking to invest in the beautiful Cape May area, as well as a travel agency to assist with all your vacation planning needs. Come experience the warm hospitality and unique atmosphere of Virginia Hotel & Cottages during your stay in Cape May.

Washington Inn & Wine Bar is a charming establishment located at 801 Washington Street in the picturesque town of Cape May, New Jersey. This institution offers a unique combination of a cozy bar, delectable food, and a wide selection of fine wines. Whether you are looking for a casual dining experience or a night out with friends, Washington Inn & Wine Bar has something for everyone. Come and enjoy the warm ambiance, delicious cuisine, and extensive wine list at this must-visit destination in Cape May.

Dormer House is a charming lodging establishment located at 800 Columbia Avenue in Cape May, New Jersey. Nestled in a picturesque neighborhood, this historic building offers guests a cozy and comfortable stay in the heart of this seaside town. The rooms are elegantly decorated and equipped with modern amenities to ensure a relaxing experience for visitors. With its convenient location, guests can easily explore the nearby attractions, including the beach, shopping areas, and local restaurants. Whether you are visiting Cape May for a weekend getaway or a longer vacation, Dormer House provides a welcoming atmosphere for all travelers.

Welcome to Shields Bike Rentals, your go-to destination for exploring the beautiful Cape May, New Jersey, on two wheels. Conveniently located at 11 Gurney Street, our family-owned and operated business has been proudly serving the community since 1991. With four generations on site daily, we are committed to providing exceptional service and unforgettable biking experiences. Open from 7 am to 7 pm, seven days a week during the season, Shields Bike Rentals offers a wide selection of high-quality bicycles to suit riders of all ages and skill levels. Each rental includes a lock, basket, and helmet at no additional charge, ensuring you have everything you need for a safe and enjoyable ride. Please note that helmets are required by law for anyone under the age of 17.

Carroll Villa Hotel is a charming lodging institution located at 19 Jackson Street in the historic town of Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This elegant Victorian-style hotel offers a unique and cozy atmosphere for guests to relax and unwind during their stay. With beautifully decorated rooms, a welcoming staff, and convenient amenities, Carroll Villa Hotel provides a comfortable and memorable experience for visitors looking to explore all that Cape May has to offer. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a weekend retreat, Carroll Villa Hotel is the perfect choice for your next stay in Cape May.

Congress Hall is a historic institution located at 200 Congress Place in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This versatile establishment offers a range of amenities including food, lodging, a restaurant, and a spa. The Sea Spa at Congress Hall provides unique ocean-inspired treatments in a bright and uplifting atmosphere. Guests can enjoy complimentary chairs and towels at the pool, with food and drink service available from the Pool Bar and Grill. Beach service is also included, with complimentary chairs, towels, and umbrellas provided on the beach in front of Congress Hall. The institution features EV Charging Stations, tennis lessons with a professional instructor, a bike shop, housekeeping services, high-speed WiFi, and access to a fitness center and sauna at the Sandpiper Beach Club. Guests can also indulge in a variety of cuisine for breakfast, lunch, and dinner without leaving the hotel grounds.

The Albert Stevens Inn is a charming lodging located at 127 Myrtle Avenue in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This cozy inn offers a comfortable and relaxing atmosphere for guests looking to enjoy a peaceful getaway. The property features a variety of amenities and services to make your stay as enjoyable as possible. Whether you have questions about the accommodations, amenities, or local attractions, the staff at Albert Stevens Inn is happy to assist you. Simply fill out the form on their website to provide feedback or ask any specific questions you may have. Don't forget to set a reminder to book your stay and receive notifications via email. Experience a memorable vacation at the Albert Stevens Inn in beautiful Cape May.

The Southern Mansion, located at 720 Washington Street in Cape May, New Jersey, is a luxurious bed and breakfast offering the largest rooms and suites in town. This historic mansion, dating back to 1860, is situated on beautifully landscaped grounds in Cape May's historic district. Just a short walk away from the best beaches, shops, and restaurants in South Jersey, The Southern Mansion provides a perfect retreat for guests. Fully restored to its original grandeur, The Southern Mansion exudes genuine Southern hospitality and offers guests absolute privacy. Indulge in gourmet cuisine and luxurious amenities that will soothe and delight your senses throughout your stay. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway, a wedding venue with a touch of Victorian charm, or a unique lodging experience, The Southern Mansion is the perfect choice. Explore our specials and experience the ultimate blend of comfort and elegance at our Cape May bed and breakfast.

The Chalfonte Hotel is a charming historic lodging located at 301 Howard Street in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This elegant hotel offers a unique blend of Victorian charm and modern amenities, providing guests with a comfortable and unforgettable stay. With its prime location near the beach and local attractions, The Chalfonte Hotel is the perfect destination for a relaxing getaway or romantic retreat. Experience the timeless beauty and hospitality of this iconic institution during your next visit to Cape May.

Stockton Inns is a charming Victorian mansion located at 809 Beach Avenue in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. With eleven uniquely different guest rooms and two spacious suites, guests can enjoy ocean views from their rooms or relax on the wrap-around porch. Perfect for families, the inn offers a variety of spacious motel-style rooms and economical efficiencies with kitchenettes. For generations, visitors to Cape May have made Stockton Inns their home at the Jersey Shore, thanks to our excellent service, diverse lodging options, and convenient beach access just steps away. Whether you choose a room in the historic Stockton Manor or the well-appointed Stockton Inn, you'll experience a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

Captain Mey's Inn is a charming turn-of-the-century Victorian inn located at 202 Ocean Street in Cape May, New Jersey, just two blocks from the beach. Our central location in the historic district allows guests to easily explore all that Cape May has to offer, including the town's best dining, shopping, and entertainment options. Guests can enjoy a comfortable stay in our beautifully appointed rooms and experience the warm hospitality of our staff. For those looking for a souvenir to remember their visit, we offer t-shirts in white, navy blue, or slate green for $20 each. Guests can purchase these shirts on-site or add them on when booking a room.

The Victorian Motel is a charming lodging establishment located at 223 Congress Place in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This historic motel offers a unique Victorian-style atmosphere with modern amenities. Guests can enjoy comfortable accommodations, friendly service, and a convenient location near the beach and local attractions. Whether you are visiting for a weekend getaway or a longer stay, the Victorian Motel provides a cozy and welcoming retreat for travelers of all kinds.

Seapointe Village is a premier oceanfront condominium resort community located in Wildwood, New Jersey. With over 230 vacation rentals to choose from, this community offers upscale homes, townhouses, and residences for ownership and vacation rental. The community is conveniently located near historic Cape May and The Wildwoods, making it a popular choice for vacations and ownership opportunities. Seapointe Village Realty LLC, a licensed real estate broker, provides unparalleled personalized service to clients in Seapointe Village and the surrounding areas. The community offers 24-hour security and a variety of exceptional amenities, including a private beach along the Atlantic Ocean, four pools with spas, tennis and pickleball courts, a fitness center, and more. The lush landscaping, waterfalls, and coastal architecture create a tropical atmosphere reminiscent of the Caribbean.

The Bayberry House is a charming lodging located at 223 Perry Street in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This historic inn offers a cozy and comfortable atmosphere for guests looking to relax and unwind. With its convenient location near the beach and local attractions, The Bayberry House is the perfect choice for a memorable stay in Cape May. The rooms are beautifully decorated and equipped with modern amenities, ensuring a pleasant and enjoyable experience for all guests. Whether you are visiting for a romantic getaway or a family vacation, The Bayberry House provides a welcoming and hospitable environment for all travelers.

Pharos at the Harrison is a charming lodging institution located at 617 Columbia Avenue in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This historic property offers guests a unique and unforgettable experience with its beautifully restored rooms and luxurious amenities. Nestled in the heart of Cape May, guests can enjoy easy access to the beach, shops, and restaurants while staying in a peaceful and elegant setting. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway or a relaxing retreat, Pharos at the Harrison is the perfect choice for your next vacation.

The Thomas Webster House Victorian is a charming lodging institution located at 933 Washington Street in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. This historic Victorian house offers guests a unique and cozy accommodation experience, with beautifully decorated rooms and a welcoming atmosphere. Guests can enjoy modern amenities while surrounded by the elegance and charm of a bygone era. Whether you are looking for a romantic getaway or a relaxing retreat, the Thomas Webster House Victorian is the perfect choice for your stay in Cape May.

Prince Albert Hall at the Queen Victoria is a luxurious lodging institution located at 509 Columbia Avenue in Cape May, New Jersey, United States. The Queen Victoria is an award-winning boutique hotel and Inn, offering guests luxury accommodations in three meticulously restored Victorian era buildings. Situated in the heart of Cape May's historic district, just one block from the beautiful beaches and two blocks from the shopping and dining district, guests will find themselves within easy walking distance of the city's many attractions. Each building at The Queen Victoria offers unique and charming Victorian style and architecture, inviting guests to explore the porches, gardens, and parlors to find their favorite. Whether you choose to stay in Prince Albert Hall or one of the other buildings, you are encouraged to make yourself at home in all of them. The corner of Ocean Street and Columbia Avenue, where the buildings are clustered, is one of Cape May's most famous and photographed corners.