TOP 10 Made from scratch pies in Indiana

Mrs. Wick's Restaurant & Pie Shop is a beloved institution located at 100 North Cherry Street in Winchester, Indiana. Originally opened by Wick himself in honor of his wife Ruby, this full-service Bakery Cafe serves up 36 varieties of delicious pies every day. Whether you're in the mood for a classic fruit pie or a savory pot pie, Mrs. Wick's has got you covered. Breakfast is served all day, and their menu also includes famous noodles, shells, and unbaked frozen pies. If you're looking to order a custom pie, just give them a call with 1 or 2 days' notice. While their inventory changes daily, you can always count on Mrs. Wick's to provide high-quality, delicious baked goods that exceed your expectations. And if you can't make it to the restaurant in person, you can have their pies shipped straight to your doorstep for a convenient and tasty treat.

Round the Clock Schererville is a beloved institution in Northwest Indiana, offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner at any time of the day or night. Located at 909 West Lincoln Highway, Schererville, Indiana, our doors are always open to serve you. Our dedicated team of bakers and chefs work tirelessly to prepare fresh, delicious meals for our customers. From homemade pies to daily soups made from scratch, we take pride in the quality of our food. Whether you're in the mood for breakfast in the afternoon or a burger in the middle of the night, Round the Clock Schererville is here to satisfy your cravings. Our ovens and grills are always ready to whip up something fantastic for you to enjoy. We strive to provide an experience that feels just like home, and our customers' satisfaction is our top priority.

Round the Clock Highland is a beloved institution located at 9010 Indianapolis Boulevard in Highland, Indiana, United States. Known as Northwest Indiana's favorite spot for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, we are always ready to serve you, no matter the time of day. Our ovens and grills are constantly on, ensuring that we can whip up a delicious meal for you whenever you're ready. Whether you're in the mood for breakfast at 3 pm or a burger at 2 am, Round the Clock Highland has got you covered. Our bakers and chefs work tirelessly each morning to provide you with fresh, homemade dishes, including pies, soups made from scratch, and other delicious options. We take great pride in the quality of our food and are dedicated to ensuring that our diners leave satisfied every time.

Jerry's Pizzeria, located at 1014 West Market Street in Logansport, Indiana, is a beloved local institution known for its delicious pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pie or a specialty pizza loaded with fresh toppings, Jerry's has something for everyone. In addition to their mouth-watering pizzas, they also offer a variety of salads, sandwiches, and appetizers to satisfy any craving. Come dine in at Jerry's Pizzeria and experience the taste of authentic, made-from-scratch pizza in a cozy setting that feels like home.

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Avon is a cozy establishment located at 121 Avon Village Parkway in Avon, Indiana. This institution offers a wide range of freshly baked goods, hearty meals, and delicious treats. From Lemon Cheesecake to Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake, and Lemon Cookies, there is something for everyone to enjoy. At MCL Restaurant & Bakery Avon, all the food is made in-house from scratch using their famously flaky pie dough, gravies, and dumplings in chicken & noodles. The belief is that homemade food tastes better and is more nourishing, which is why they take pride in preparing everything with care and attention to detail.

Cafe Audrey at Fort Ben, located at 9134 Otis Avenue in Indianapolis, Indiana, offers a delightful breakfast and lunch experience in the historic Fort Benjamin Harrison. You can enjoy a variety of dishes such as classic breakfast options like eggs cooked any style with a choice of sides, made-from-scratch pancakes, and hearty skillets. The menu also includes delicious custard pies, breakfast sandwiches, and omelets with a selection of fillings. For those with a sweet tooth, there are options like Egg Nog Brioche French Toast and Blueberry Lemon Pancakes. Additionally, the cafe serves a range of beverages including locally roasted coffees, teas, mimosas, and specialty cocktails like Bloody Marys and Bellinis. Whether you're looking for a hearty breakfast or a light and refreshing meal, Cafe Audrey at Fort Ben has something for everyone. Please note that some menu items may contain raw or undercooked ingredients, and a gratuity of 18% is automatically added to parties of 8 or more. Gluten-free bread and pancake options are also available for those with dietary restrictions. Visit Cafe Audrey for a delicious and satisfying dining experience in a charming setting.

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Carmel is a beloved institution located at 1390 Keystone Way in Carmel, Indiana, United States. This versatile establishment offers a variety of delicious options including bakery items, food, and restaurant dishes. For a limited time in April, guests can enjoy special treats such as Lemon Cheesecake, Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake, and Lemon Cookies.