Broad Street Oyster Company

"Came here to have dinner on a Saturday night with some friends. You place your order inside the shop at the counter first and it's self seating outside under a covered patio. It was fairly crowded around 7:15 but still had a place to sit. They have picnic style benches. We ordered a dozen oysters, clam chowder, battered fish tacos, lobster rolls, and mussels, and chilled red wine. So if you like seafood this spot is terrific. The food was fantastic and filling. The staff is friendly and atmosphere is nice too."

"Nice spot that’s in a cool mini mall type place. Food was great although the portions are on the small side for the price. I ordered shrimp and fries for $17 and it came with literally 4 shrimps and fries. Not jumbo shrimp either. The lobster roll was absolutely perfect tho and one of the best ones I’ve had. The sitting and order situation still gives off Covid vibes, with no indoor seating and just walk up to order and pick up. You have to wait comically far back before the cashier calls you up to order. Tried the party wine can also and it was tasty but it was also overpriced. Will absolutely be back for another lobster roll tho !"

"I found this place during covid and have been coming since. However, I feel like they’re not the same anymore. The lobster rolls are so tiny now and amount of lobster that is on the roll seems lot less compared to before.. yes inflation blah blah I know but it’s still disappointing. The food is good staff is friendly but I think I will fulfill my lobster roll cravings somewhere closer instead of driving 30-40mins."

"For $30 I wasn’t expecting to be able to hold my lobster roll comfortably with one hand without fear of lobster falling out. The garlicky sweet/savory (small) hot-dog sized roll is delicious and makes up the majority of the sandwich. It’s barely cracked open and topped with tasty lobster (not filled, topped). When I first picked up my to go bag I thought they forgot to put the sandwich in it was so light. Absolutely delicious but the ratio of lobster:bread is horribly off. I’d need to eat at least 3-5 of those to feel full and they need to add at least 40-50% more lobster for the ratio to be right. Expect this to be about 25% of the size of what you’d find on the East coast. Staff were very friendly!"

"From someone who lives on the east coast I was excited to drive up the Pacific Coast Highway. And what better way to enjoy that drive than with some fantastic seafood in a relaxed vibe. It might not have direct ocean views, but eating on the picnic tables outside under the shade with the freshest of seafood options was worth it. It was my first time trying live sea urchin and is definitely worth a try. The lobster in the roll was cooked perfectly and enhanced with simple drawn butter, rather than soaked in mayo like most lobster rolls. Made me wish I chose their whole lobster special at the counter when ordering."