Great American Cookies 1495 Saint Louis Galleria Street, St. Louis, MO 63117

"Ordered the biggest cookie cake. It was ready at the promised time and the order was accurate. However, the flavor of the cookie cake was extremely disappointing. Especially considering how much it cost. It was also so thin you couldn’t even put a candle in it. We’ve always gotten cookie cakes from Schnucks or Dierbergs, but they only make the small circle ones now. Theirs tasted so much better and were less than half the price."

"definitely not as good as it used to bc i dont remember this being an issue: love the white (vanilla) and brown (chocolate) icing, but the colored icing tastes SO bad. i got hot pink detailing around the cookie cake and every bite i immediately get the weirdest taste and aftertaste in my mouth, its almost like playdough. this doesnt happen with the vanilla or chocolate, so if you dont like the flavor of playdough or straight food dye, do not get colored icing here."

"Had a cookie cake made for my husband, Lola took care of us, was really nice and extra accommodating, she made my husbands day."

"Cookies not as good as they used to be and they tell you one price then mysteriously a couple more dollars show up on my account. I believe they are running some type of scam. Next time I visit I'll definitely be asking for a receipt. This only happens when I don't ask for one."

"I ordered a custom cake and asked for a custom drawing of a goat. I'm sure the custom drawing requests are annoying but they did a great job! I love it and I think its very funny. As long as you don't expect them to create a complicated masterpiece they deliver. And on time too! It was ready as soon as I arrived."