ellenJAY Bakery

"Wanted something special for my son's birthday party, they were perfect."

"The best of the best! I wish I could give more than 5 stars. They don’t do custom cakes - but will accommodate and change colors around to match the theme! Great price for even greater quality!!! The most helpful and nicest ladies as well!"

"Update: I changed my rating because I placed a pre-order on Sunday for pickup on Wednesday. The pick up window is 2:00 to 4:00 p.m. When I arrived my order was not ready. They told me it would be another 30 minutes because they were baking. They could have text or called to say that the order would not be ready or that it would be delayed. I emailed and called after I left the bakery. I received a email at 7:02 p.m. that I could pick up the items that I ordered the following day. When I called the bakery directly, I left a voicemail and I never received a call back. The Sammies are good the customer service could have been a much better. I see in other reviews that they do text or call when the ordering is delayed, maybe they only do that for regular customers. ********* ellenJay is amazing, just amazing!! I'm not usually in Midtown but today I decided to make a special trip to ellenJay. It's hard to resist this adorable Bakery boutique because customer service is wonderful and the Buttercream Peanut butter Sammies, Lemon Tea Cakes and that Sweet Potato cupcake are out of this world. I decided to get a few things because I'm not on that side of town often and I'm so glad I did. It took me a few days to get through everything and it was definitely worth it. As I entered, I was greeted by a smiling eyes and display case of baked goodness. It was hard for me decide what to order, so I asked to recommendations. I can't remember the lady's name and she had a mask on so it's hard to recognize if she was one of the owners. But she was so very helpful and friendly. She recommended the Sweet Potato cupcake. She said it was a customer favorite and after taking one bite, I know why. Next, the Buttercream Sammy, I chose the Peanut Butter because its.. peanut butter and I love peanut butter. I've had Sammies before but this one is by far the best. The buttercream was light and the cookie was absolutely perfect. It is everything you hope a Peanut Butter cookie would be and so much more. I'm a huge fan of lemon and she said the Tea cake was a moist cookie with a bold lemon flavor and she was right. It was delicious. Check out their website, they offer shipping and curbside pickup. I see a curbside pickup for some cupcakes and a Peanut Butter Sammie, in the not to distant future. See ya there"

"EllenJay is literally amazing!! They made my wedding cake and dessert bar and it's something that guests still talk about to this day (almost 2 years later)! I'm a wedding photographer as well and EllenJay always does such a great job! I get excited when I see their names on the vendor list because I know I'm in for a treat! HIRE THEM!!!"