Amish Creamery Co 211 150th Avenue, Madeira Beach, FL 33708

"Clint the owner is the sweetest. The ice cream is about 5x better than any other ice cream in this area… it’s DELICIOUS. We Re locals and are newly obsessed. I wouldn’t go anywhere else for ice cream. Highly recommend."

"All the ice cream is freshly made. The staff was cheerful and we talked a lot while he offered us samples and then made our treats. The blueberry cheesecake ice cream was out of this world. I’ve always hated cheesecake ice cream but this one is amazing. The butterscotch explosion ice cream is very unique too. I’ve never had butterscotch ice cream & this one was loaded with all sorts of yummy mix-ins. The store doesn’t have a place to sit down or dine inside though which is a shame. They offer plenty of their ice cream flavors to go by the pint and quart. They sell a few other Amish offerings too like jams & cookies."

"everything was amazing PLEASE TRY THIS PLACE!!!! instead of going to some of this more seen ice cream places u absolutely have to try this one!! the service was amazing, everyone was very friendly. the building was clean and neat and the ice cream… man.. the ice cream was OUTSTANDING. very rich and creamy, tons of flavors as well to choose from. give this place a try"

"Deliciously creamy and a wide variety of flavors They serve Yoder's homemade out of Sarasota and regularly refresh the supply. The only downside could be the price - not the MOST expensive around, but high quality demands top dollar."

"I recently had the pleasure of visiting Amish Creamery Co., and I must say, it was an unforgettable experience. From the moment we stepped in, Clint's customer service was nothing short of exceptional – a solid 10 out of 10. Not only did he make us feel incredibly welcome, but he also took the time to share insights into his culture and the art of crafting their delicious ice cream. Clint's warmth and kindness truly shone through, making us feel like part of the family. Learning about the Amish culture added a unique and enriching layer to our visit, making it more than just a stop for ice cream. Speaking of ice cream, let me tell you, it was phenomenal. Finding both delicious and genuinely healthy treats can be challenging, but Amish Creamery Co. nailed it. Every scoop was a perfect balance of flavor and quality ingredients. But what truly sets this place apart is Clint himself. His genuine care for his customers and passion for his craft make Amish Creamery Co. a true hidden gem. I left with a full heart and an even fuller belly, eager to spread the word and support this wonderful business. Thank you, Clint, for an unforgettable experience. Your kindness and attention to detail truly made our visit special. I wholeheartedly recommend everyone to support Amish Creamery Co. – not just for the incredible ice cream, but for the outstanding service and warm hospitality."