Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.) 878 Montauk Highway, Shirley, NY 11967

"Tried getting a quote online and received a call from a Joe. Joe tells me to call the office as he will be in until 6PM. I call much earlier than that, only to be told by some airhead that Joe is “not in today” and that the office was “a little busy” so they were unable to quote me. I mean, I expect this kind of behavior from a business in Shirley, but still. As someone who works in the insurance business this is extremely unprofessional."

"Island Wide Insurance was very kind and helpful. I needed coverage quickly and they helped me find a great deal. I definitely recommend them. Thanks Kelly!"

"I came to Island Wide when I was at my lowest and everything seemed to be going wrong. I couldn’t afford any of the prices the “big name” insurance companies were giving me. Kelly helped me through everything. She was compassionate, understanding, and explained everything so I made sure I knew what was going on. The office is clean and everyone there is so nice. Just yesterday i didn’t know if I could even get insurance and today I walked out with everything taken care of. Thank you Kelly for helping me with all of this!!!!"

"Highly recommend! The entire office was great but I worked with Joe specifically and he was amazing. He was able to help me with things other companies weren’t able to, answered all my questions and I didn’t feel rushed. He really took his time to help me and give me the best quote possible for my vehicle. He was very honest and kind in the entire process. 10/10 worth checking them out!"

"Island Wide Insurance Agency exceeded my expectations with their exceptional service and affordability. The team was incredibly helpful throughout the entire process, addressing my concerns and guiding me to the most suitable insurance options. Their commitment to providing assistance made navigating the complexities of insurance a much smoother experience. What stood out most was their dedication to affordability without compromising on quality coverage. In an industry where costs can often be a concern, Island Wide Insurance Agency managed to strike a balance that allowed me to secure the protection I needed without breaking the bank. I appreciate the transparency and clarity they offered, making it easy for me to understand my policy and its benefits. This positive experience has undoubtedly made me a satisfied customer, and I would highly recommend Island Wide Insurance Agency to others seeking reliable and budget-friendly insurance solutions."