St Catherine of Siena Hospital: Tamayo Luther R MD 50 New York 25A, Smithtown, NY 11787

"Stay away from this hospital, do yourself a favor and go somewhere else, negative reviews on the web are true. So sad because I been going there for years and the service has declined terribly. Good luck to patients who go there you will need it."

"I would never go to this emergency room again. The admitting nurse and doctor were totally burnt out and rude and opinionated. I was set up with an IV and a half hour later, I look down and they left the garbage on me. The doctor had no communication skills and was just plain "not nice.". A good excuse would be that they were very busy, however, it was a very quiet night, and only a few patients. Horrible experience. They wanted to admit me and I took a chance and asked to be discharged. My vitals were better and I got the heck out of that place."

"To: St Catherines Staff, I wanted to thank everyone at St. Catherines for the outstanding service that was provided last week to my daughter, Christie Martinez. Everyone from the nurses to the doctors, dieticians, and administrative staff were super friendly and helpful. We could not have asked for a better hospital experience anywhere. Most important was the treatment they gave my daughter, which allowed her to make a speedy recovery. Please keep up the great work; you are truly our heroes.  Thank you all! Best Regards Moraima Lopez & Christie Martinez"

"I went to the emergency room yesterday by myself and I was treated with very quick and excellent service. It was very clean and the nurses were always around helping. The biggest concern I had was actually being exposed to Covid-19 by being in a hospital environment. As soon as I walked in, we I no longer had that concern whatsoever. I was so impressed. You wouldn't usually use the word pleasant after going to an emergency room but even though I was in terrible pain, it was actually a very pleasant visit. Thank you to the Nurse Manager and Matt, ER Nurse and the doctor on call yesterday morning. Everyone was amazing! Thank you! Karin"