Oconee Diner 749 Montauk Highway, Islip, NY 11751

"This restaurant really celebrates the holidays. Went here a few days before July 4 and there were banners and flags everywhere! I am told they do this for all the holidays! Food was good, staff was friendly. The restaurant was clean. Will definitely come again next time we are in the area!"

"Lovely diner on the South Shore of Long Island. Always so festive, and never a complaint on the food. The staff is very friendly and always asking how you are doing. Family owned and run for generations. At times coffee needs to be made fresh but other than that four stars for sure. Great place to hold small to mid size parties. Reasonable prices across the menu."

"The food was very disappointing. It's not that hard to make a Rueban sandwich. The bread was soggy, and it looks like they just threw a load of slop onto two pieces of bread. I couldn't even eat it without the whole thing falling apart. Another strange thing is that the food was served about two minutes after we finished ordering. To me, it seems like they rushed. My boyfriend ordered a burger and couldn't finish it without feeling nauseous. He said it had a strange flavor and could not take another bite. The service wasn't great. Although the waitress was friendly, she hardly gave us enough time to decide what drinks to order. The atmosphere felt like a fever dream. The lighting was giving me a headache. The decorations along with the weird food just made the whole dining experience feel like a bad LSD trip. I wouldn't recommend eating here, unless you want a weird spooky experience."

"Wonderful Holiday Experience at Oconee Diner! Me and my Family, recently visited Oconee Diner and was delighted by their beautiful Christmas decorations. The lights and holiday decor created a really warm and festive atmosphere. The staff were friendly and made sure we had a great experience. The food was delicious, with a good variety of choices, and everything was fresh and well-presented. We were super impressed by how clean and well-kept the diner was. It made the meal even more enjoyable. We left feeling very happy and in the holiday spirit. We highly recommend Oconee Diner for anyone looking for great food in a lovely, festive setting. Definitely a five-star experience!"

"No matter what holiday it is, or in between them, this is an excellent diner on Long Island! They are always decked out in decorations (roof to lawn...ceiling to tables) that will put you in the holiday spirit. Service is always great...fast, friendly, efficient servers, chefs that know how to cook, etc. The food is large portions, so expect to bring home leftovers. We have tried breakfast, lunch, and dinner...all are great, never a disappointment. Btw, they know how to cook eggs, I know that can be a deal breaker."