Mama's Oakdale 587 Montauk Highway, Oakdale, NY 11769

"I've been ordering Sicilian pizza my entire life, this pizza is pathetic. Everything has gone up , we all too dollar and there is minimum cheese, nothing like sicillian. Awful. Waste of money. Del by Door dash asked to be handed to me, left on cement ground, when I realized outside ice cold. Note: it's very hot here. What is wrong with that driver!!!"

"We’ve gotten good pizza from here before as takeout, but the dine-in experience was pretty horrible. This place needs to be staffed better, we waited for over 90 minutes to get food for two people (two plates of pasta without meat or anything fancy) and the whole time it seems as though the entire dining room was being managed by a singular waitress. Food was not worth the wait, the salad we got was clearly unwashed lettuce, and the Alfredo we ordered was basically inedible. our server was really helpful and friendly the entire time and seemed as though she was doing her best, but the bottom line is that it was just way too much for one person. I hope and pray that they were short because someone called out, and that there isn’t normally a lack of staffing like this."

"My wife and I have been ordering holiday and personal take out dinner's for a while. All I can say eccellente!!!!! Food is the best espcially there sauce, Thank you"

"My wife and I visited yesterday afternoon for their pasta special. We live nearby, but we haven’t been here in years. Friends have told us to give it another try, and we loved our meals and the service. Kyle was our server, and he welcomed us both just as he did his many “regulars”. I had the rigatoni di Spago and she had the Penne Rigate Alla Bellini. The servings are more than enough for 2-3 meals, and their homemade lentil soup was also excellent. This place is a hidden gem, and we will become frequent customers. Thank you, Kyle and your team!"

"Friday night is go out to dinner night...and a treat indeed to find such a gem. Home cooking with no waiting! Cozy and warm, friendly and delicious. Generous portions with a full menu and reasonable prices. We’ll be back!"