Carlo's Pizza Shirley 451 Glen Drive, Shirley, NY 11967

"I don’t expect a lot from a pizzeria, especially their service. This is a great place for a quick bite. To go is a great choice. The pizza is worth the price. They recently came up with a new pepperoni pizza - I don’t remember the name, but it was hot honey pepperoni sth. This was good"

"JUST STATING A FACT: I believe the children chatting behind the counter, need to be managed by an adult, who has some interest in this business establishment. Enter for dinner asked if we could be seated in restaurant area, response was yeah sit anywhere you like. After seating ourselves At one of the filthy tables and continuously Making eye contact with the young lady who told us to do so, we sat for ten minutes, while she chatted up with her fellow employees . Never did we have a waiter or waitress address our existence. Can’t rate the food But the service was dismal. This establishment must be losing a copious amount of business, due to the unsupervised children behind the counter. ONCE IS ENOUGH…."

"Great job you dummy’s means the guy isn’t cooking the pizzas right won’t even come off in slices knew you still stunk worst pizza the Carlos in Holbrook is great the one in Shirley is horrible pizza falls apart as I’m trying to break slices apart"

"The kids that work there are rude from answering the phones to even talking in person. Then when you question the burnt calazone (which they agreed was burnt) still had an attitude. The food is subpar and not worth the attitudes they give for the convenience of the location. The food at the Manorville location is a million times better. I’m done getting attitudes from children I rather drive further away. I guess their parents never thought them manners."

"This is the perfect place to get a quick bite or order to go! The pizza is always fresh and hot. And really worth it's price. I do recommend a classic pepperoni or just plain cheese. But any choice is perfect."