DiFiore's Ice Cream Delite

"We used to go here frequently when we were staying in the neighborhood. Service is never stellar but used to be okay. Today the service was Doug’s and the ice cream was flavorless and extremely overpriced. The soft serve was melting before we were even handed the ice cream and the whole thing fell apart so fast and it’s not even hot out. The flavor was barely there and we ended up paying over $15 for 2 small cones. Not worth it. Just go to Page’s. Much better ice cream and service."

"Some of the best ice cream I've ever had. Bar none. And I've been around. Regarding the older man there, he was a bit short, but it didn't bother me in any way, shape, or form. Would go back. Again and again and again. Edit: After I originally shared this review, I did, in fact, go back. I complimented the older gentleman's ice cream and upon hearing what I had to say, he lit right up, smiles and all."

"Not the best experience. The ice cream was mediocre at best, and overpriced to boot. The ice cream flavor was caramel vanilla pretzel which seemed promising, but I could taste mint the whole time... don't know if it was stored too close to a mint flavor or if the scooper wasn't rinsed. The cherry vanilla had maraschino cherries, which tasted very fake. Main reasons for the low rating: No cards were accepted, so we had to visit an ATM, no tastes available...the reason was covid (Still?...why?), server was unfriendly, and no extra napkins were offered even with it being a very hot day. My final comment is that it was disappointing to get ice cream no better than a cheap grocery store brand, yet have to pay a top shelf price. If we could have tasted it, we wouldn't have bought it. Not going back...ever!"

"I was exceedingly disappointed with DiFiore's Ice Cream. I went for lunch on a visit to Pittsburgh, and our group ordered a Club Sandwich, a Fish Sandwich, and Perogies. To start, the Perogies were undercooked and were very soggy. The Club Sandwich was average but was exceedingly overpriced. The fish sandwich was good, but the bun was way too small, and the sandwich was sizzling hot and burned my tongue. This would not be a problem if I was warned about its heat, but I was not. And going back to the pricing, the pricing was ridiculous for the food we were being served. When talking about the service, I have to separate the wonderful lady who was taking our order and the insolent owner. The lady who took our order was kind, but we were being glared at by the owner in the background the whole time during our order at the side window. When we were full, I ended up going back to the window to get a box, but after repedly trying to call for the lady, I overheard her being yelled at by the rude owner. There are also some very odd policies there that seem extremely outdate. The two in question are that there is a storefront, but apparently, it is closed to the public, and you are only allowed to use the side window. The second is a cash only policy. This just is not convenient, especially in 2024, when some people only pay using digital cards on their phone. If you care about yourself and the employees of this shop, do not go here and support its crooked owner."