Papa GeGe's Italian Villa
About the Business
Welcome to Papa GeGe's Italian Villa, where tradition and taste meet to create an unforgettable dining experience. Nestled in the heart of New Middletown, Ohio, at 19 Sycamore Drive, our restaurant is a sanctuary for lovers of authentic Italian cuisine. From the bustling kitchens of New Castle to the charming dining rooms of our Villa, our journey has been one of passion, dedication, and culinary excellence.
At Papa GeGe's, we believe in the magic of flavors and the power of a well-crafted dish. Our menu offers a delightful array of mouthwatering options, each meticulously crafted to capture the true essence of Italian cooking. Savor our classic Sunday Sauce, a rich blend inspired by cherished family traditions, or try our tantalizing Blush Sauce, a heavenly combination of Sunday Sauce and Alfredo. For those who crave a little heat, our Diablo Sauce adds an extra kick to your favorite dishes.
What sets us apart is our unwavering commitment to quality. We use only the finest ingredients—fresh produce, artisanal cheeses, and premium meats—to ensure that every bite resonates with authenticity. Whether you choose to dine in or pick up, our focus remains on preserving the essence of Italian cuisine while offering the convenience of enjoying homemade flavors at home.
Exciting news for our patrons: Papa GeGe's Italian Villa is now open and ready to serve you at both our Boardman and New Middletown locations! We are currently hiring for all positions and appreciate your patience as our new staff learns to meet our high standards of service. Please note that online orders will not be available at the New Middletown location for a few weeks. However, you can place pick-up orders by calling 234-759-3156.
And don't forget, you can now bring a piece of Papa GeGe's home with you by ordering our signature sauces, shipped directly to your house. Experience the adventure of our culinary legacy, one delicious bite at a time, right from the comfort of your own kitchen.
Join us at Papa GeGe's Italian Villa and become part of our family tradition, where every meal is a celebration of life, love, and the timeless joy of great food.
Photos
Location & Phone number
19 Sycamore Dr, New Middletown, OH 44442, United States
Hours open
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
Closed
Wednesday:
3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Thursday:
3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Friday:
3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Saturday:
2:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Sunday:
12:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Reviews
"was $40 for two meals without drinks or any appetizers. wasn’t very good either."
"Lovely place and the food is fantastic."
"I looked at their online menu for pricing. When I called the person on the phone repeated my order back wrong three times! When my husband picked up the order I told him to make sure it was correct. They charged him $30 for a pepperoni pizza that should’ve cost $24.99 according to their online menu on their own website. This was our first time ordering and we thought we would start out with pizza just to see how the service was and the food. We are very disappointed with the initial phone call to place our order and of course being overcharged six dollars did not help anything. We still did give the pizza a fair chance. We were sorely disappointed. The cheese was bland and didn’t have that tangy salty taste cheese should have on a pizza The pepperoni was cheap and there was oil all over the pizza. The next day the pepperoni did crisp up a bit more but was still bland. The sauce was okay. Overall, this was a bad experience and we will not be back."
"Very good pizza"
"Hope you are hungry. Large portions, delicious pizza, fantastic antipasto salad, sausage pepper roll is just like grandma's."
List of local businesses, places and services in Ohio
⭐ business help 🔍 services ☎ phones 🕒 opening times ✍️reviews 🌍 addresses, locations 📷 photos