Silver Mill Restaurant

"We were passing by and stumbled upon this gem! We had the shrimp scampi, tenderloin special with grilled brussel sprouts and cauliflower on a savory sauce, and the soup flight. My husband usually doesn't like veggies and he ate it up! The dishes were all very beautifully presented and super delicious! The staff was also very personable and friendly. We were glad we stopped by - what a great dining experience!"

"I ordered a Bayern Helles and sirloin steak, mash, and veggies. The waitress asked me if I wanted to upgrade the sirloin cut to a picanha cut for a bit more. It was topped with some chive flowers sauteed in butter, and it was delicious. I plan to grow some chives so I can try to make this at home. My veggie child got the pepper jack garden cheesburger, and fries. They were very happy, and finished their food, before starting to nibble on my mash and veggies. It was a little slow, which I think is great. I had time to quiz the waitress about the ingredients (I thought the steak was topped with garlic blossoms, not chive blossoms), and spent some time talking to the (I'm guessing) owner about the selection of gins and tequilas. I have some gins and tequilas to buy now."

"After spending the day wandering around Phillipsburg, we stopped in at the Siler Mill for a late lunch. It has the dark wood and rich leather feel of an excellent steakhouse and bar, but we experienced it as exhausted parents. The staff knew what we'd need and found an out-of-the-way corner for us to setup with two adults, an infant, and a toddler. The food was just right. And if you ask for it, they have the best cups and bendy straws for kids."

"Everything was fantastic! I had the Nashville Hot Chicken sandwich. Chicken was juicy and the hot chicken sauce was super flavorful. My wife got the steak sandwich and it was also cooked to perfection. My mother-in-law got the chicken plate. She loved the greens, one of the sides it came with, so much she ordered another helping. Service was also great and friendly. I will absolutely be back again and recommend everyone stop in and give it a go!"

"We had a wonderful New Year’s Eve dinner/party there. The food was very good, the service also. The atmosphere, with a fabulous live band (local, even!) was fun - there was also an option to dress up in 20’s garb and have our picture taken and printed out (included with dinner!). The owner and the chef came out to talk with us (and apparently we were already well know because of the international party that called and left a message for a reservation). All in all a very pleasant way to spend the early New Year’s Eve with our son."