Thee Pitts Again

"Update: I understood the order set up perfectly fine. We waited INSIDE to place an order for about 20 min because there was only ONE person who took orders. Yes, this is a slow service for those on a road trip. They have two vegan options. We got vegan sloppy Joe. It tasted okay. Service is slow, and you have to order inside."

"This place did not live up to the hype. The town was very busy the day we visited, but we were able to order right away. The food was really mediocre and not what you would expect. We ordered the brisket sandwichs, potato salad, mashed potatoes, onion rings. The portions are pretty small. The brisket sandwich was ok, but bland and really needs a ton of bbq sauce. The bun wasn't toasted so it became soggy. The onion rings were super crispy and home made but tasted like Chinese food. It was odd. The potato salad was great, and the meal came with a yummy pickle. Overall I wish we had of stayed at the pizza place, but the wait was over 30 mins."

"BBQ restaurant in the heart of Silverton. Famous from Guy Fieri’s feature in Diners Drive Ins and Dives. I like that they have vegan options - their veg sloppy joe was tasty. Nice outdoor dog friendly seating area."

"They are living off of Guy Fieri visiting them back in 2008 on his show Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives, some 15 years ago. A lot can change in 15 years IE owners, menus, recipes, etc. I really love barbecue and enjoy trying different ones. When walk into the place it’s like a dust bowl, it hits right in the face. It’s dark and dirty. Nobody eats inside cause it’s to dirty! I ordered the brisket, which is my favorite thing to get at barbecue places. An what I got looked more like pulled port! It was broken up into little pieces and watery, like they served me the crumbs from the day. Good brisket comes in slices with a nice outer layer of charred “bark” , that gives it’s smoke flavor and soft and moist inside. This was no where close to that! You will be able to see from the picture what they served as brisket. The brisket didn’t even have a smoke flavor or taste like it had been smoked. The side of baked beans I got tasted like they were straight out of a van. No Smokey barbecue flavor. This place as no competition in town so they probably can get away with serving this. Tourists pass thru here everyday in the summer. Don’t waste your time or money. Note: Brisket pic will be first one UPDATE: AFTER OWNER RESPONDED. About 3 or 4 reviews down you clearly state that the brisket is not minced but sliced fresh everyday, not chipped. Care to elebrate why you tell me its chipped and this guy it was sliced? An my comment regarding the building was not cause of it being an old building, it was regarding all the dust and dirt you can see. When was the last time your barbcue won an award? inquiring minds would like to know."

"Visiting from out of town and I love me some BBQ. So when the wife pointed out it's a Trip DDD spot, I was down to try it. I ordered the dinner beef brisket with mashed potatoes / gravy and baked beans. Wife got the brisket-lite option (see pics for reference). For dessert we had the peach pie a-la-mode and a Coors. Food; I thought the brisket was 3-stars good. The beans and taters were okay, the corn bead a bit flavorless. Price: Didn't get an itemized breakdown but my bill was $60 Service; The service was good. The counter guy answered a couple questions for us and recommended the pie, which was really good. Our food was brought out to our outside table. It came quickly and everything was hot. The a-la-mode was brought out after we finished eating. The pie was hot, the ice cream was plenty and the taste was great. Plenty of seating inside and out. The interior was decorated with hodgepodge all over the walls and on every flat surface. Instead of a homey, abstract, weird feel, It makes it look dingy and dirty. There's no way to clean all of the decorations, and it shows. The food was good, could use some tweaks, but good overall. Lots of places to drop your dollar, I would try a different spot next visit. The city is amazing!"