Eagan Carbone's

"I was staying at the Marriott next door and walked here for some good pizza and was not disappointed. Get the deep dish. It’s really good pizza and way more authentic than Punch. In May I’m be coming back for training and will try the thin crust."

"My food did not come as ordered(did not get what was paid for as "extra"). My pizza was practically glued to the box it came in. Very underwhelming. And to top it off, found a hair melted into the cheese. Yeah pretty sure I'm not coming back. For the cost, it should have been a very different experience."

"EDIT—I’ve upgraded the review to 4 stars overall because the general manager reached out on the app and requested I call her to discuss what happened. We spoke a few days later and she apologized greatly for our experience and said we should not have been treated like we were and said they are addressing it. She gave us a store credit that covered what we spent that first visit as well as an additional amount for a future visit and asked us to give them another try. She was very sincere and I felt she properly addressed the situation. I am pleased with the outcome and we will give them another try. — This was the worst restaurant experience we’ve had in a while. Saturday, 11/04/2023, 7:00pm and about half full. I ordered a 10” pepperoni and my partner ordered a 10” taco pizza. Mine came out and the waitress didn’t say anything-just walked off. My partner told me to go ahead and start as hers wouldn’t be far behind. A little bit later, pizzas were taken to a table that came in about 20 minutes after us. I was already halfway done. My partner said there was no point staying since I was almost done so when the waitress returned I asked her to just box up the pizza since I was almost done and let her know it was frustrating not to eat together. The waitress said that it takes longer to cook the taco pizza than the pepperoni. I told her I would expect a restaurant to know how to cook in order to serve a table all at once and asked for a manager. She replied, “I am the manager”, and walked off. No apology, no offer to rectify the situation. Received the bill in full, no apology, no request to come back and no box for the remaining pieces of my pizza. We got home after an 8 minute drive and my partner opened the pizza was was cold. Not warm at all-it did not just get done. Interestingly, there were also no tortilla chips on the pizza-they were still in the bag. It appears that maybe it was packaged for pick up instead of for a customer in the restaurant? At any rate. There was no accountability, apology or compensation for a ruined dinner out."

"Note to self: Know your Italian cuisine before ordering. I wanted an antipasto salad but mistakenly ordered a side salad instead. My mistake however the waitress was eager to replace my salad with the antipasto, I thought it would be wasteful so I ate the salad. Not what I wanted but delicious, nonetheless. I'll just have to come back and order the right thing next time. Happy good mistake!"

"Got the large thin with double pepperoni and extra cheese. Came out hot and tasty. As leftover pizza, it’s not my best. Also had the Caesar Salad with a side of cheese bread that was good."