Tolsma Auto Body 211 Evans Street, Caldwell, ID 83605

"The lady who takes the calls is horrible at communicating , she will say “it will be ready this day” and so on then will extend it by 4 days. Then when you call them to see she says she will call you back but you always have to end up calling yourself she needs to be fired if i could give this place 0 stars i would! DO NOT GO HERE! Spend your money someplace else!"

"It seems as if Tony the owner of the shop has turned into a dishonest, insurance fraud. My roommate, who is a Filipino native, has been defrauded out of her car, and also the insurance company has been defrauded of thousands of dollars, for body work that Tony has promised to do for my roommate , since the beginning of July . Shame on him. She is an early 70s year old woman, and she was recently widowed. Also a first-time driver in the United States if I can give him a zero I would. She still doesn't have her car."

"If you have a nicer vehicle/sports car, please please do yourself a favor and go else where for paintwork. After bringing my car back twice I'm still finding clear coat runs, nibs, and even imperfections at the base coat level of paint that can't be fully removed. The orange peel was pretty bad and didn't match the original finish at all. I've had it and I'm now wet sanding and polishing their mistakes which I find completely unacceptable. My original taillights were also improperly installed and were held in place with structural adhesive. They did own up to that and buy me some new ones. After constantly finding these new issues with my paint every time I see it under different lighting, I'm completely fed up and wishing I had gone else where. They did a decent job with everything else related to the body repair. The owner was friendly and I held back on leaving a bad review but I feel people should know this so they don't potentially have a bad experience."

"Tony the owner is SO rude, I feel so bad for the people that work there. They did an okay job painting the car when the grandson was running the business but it took probably 2 months to get our car back. It was always something! Thankfully not our every day driver so not a huge deal. Got the car back and left side headlights and blinker didn't work. Turns out they forgot to connect a fuse box but the owner literally didn't believe me and proceeded to argue with me over the phone. Tech that helped me today was AMAZING and the gal that works up front is super nice. But if you're looking for high quality speedy service I'd probably try somewhere else!"

"A tow truck company crashed my car into my garage and their truck. Tolsma has a very long wait, but they're awesome!! Bookings are 3½ to 4 months out right now, but you should just wait and have Tolsma Auto do it if you want it looking like new."