Papa Johns Pizza,

2681 Windsor Street, Sun Prairie, WI 53590

"Got their pizza the first or second week it was open, and everything was fantastic. We then ordered again tonight, and clearly the corporate startup crew has left the building. Absolutely pathetic. We ordered at 5:30, and it said the food would be ready by 6-6:10. I showed up at 6:05 to a complete zoo. There were 15+ people standing in the lobby all very frustrated. The employees were cracking jokes and moving at the pace of a snail, they seemed to find it hilarious how swamped they were. The young lady making the crust and another young man were flirting loudly and giggling about the order or something they were working on, they had no haste whatsoever. The “manager” was walking around acting like a hot shot but not actually working towards getting her employees working faster or better at all. In fact, as she walked to the register she shouted out a pizza to make and laughed as she did it. When she finally asked me how she can help me, I told her I had an online order and she told me it would be another 30+ minutes. I immediately asked to cancel my order and left. She said she was sorry and that they “had two people walk out” - but if the 5 employees there actually tried to do their jobs well they could have easily handled the rush and gotten food to their customers. I tried to call when I got home so I could find out how to contact the owner, and they literally ignored the call and it went right to holding music. What a pathetic experience."

"Sorry Shaq, this pizza just isnt good. Crust is literally paper thin, nothing to it. The garlic dipping sauce was half opened. I wasnt expecting much and never get chain pizza & this is why. Im not even mad, its just funny people think this is good pizza."

"Ordered take out. Staff was very friendly. Pizzas were ready so fast and were delicious. Will definitely be back soon."

"Used to get Papa John's with my family as a kid, happy to see one back in town. We got a pepperoni and sausage pizza, it was delicious. My dad used to make us eat the peppers, so seeing the pepper in the box was a funny memory."

"Finally open and Papa John would be proud. I was order number 4 on their first day and they nailed it. Parking was crowded for a pick up but otherwise fast, friendly and most of all it was as tasty as I expect from locations open longer. So, no concerns being an early customer for this location. Welcome to the neighborhood Papa John!"