Mama Mia's 8533 West Greenfield Avenue, West Allis, WI 53214

"Incredible garlic bread, as they seem to be known for. Definitely had a wow factor for the size alone, which is expanded upon by the intense garlic flavor. Mozzarella sticks are huge and breaded with garlic bread crumbles (ends of the loaf). Delicious My wife had the lasagna, which was everything you want...cheesy, saucy, meaty and tasty. I had the Chicken Parm over Spaghetti, which was more of the same. On top of this, we left with an entire extra entree (lasagna plus garlic bread), leftovers for at least 2 more meals, extra appetizer we didn't finish, and all for under $70 including tip. Kind of sad we didn't find this gem earlier, but I have a super high standard for Italian so I'm hesitant to try new places. Luckily, now I don't have to."

"Antipasta salad with garlic bread never disappoints! The lasagna was Good, yet so filling, I could only eat half. I normally only get pizza, which is the cheesiest! Customer service was great as well. I called in takeout order on my way & it was ready quickly and the young lady was very nice."

"Service is really good and their food is amazing. I was so full after our dinner. Very affordable price. Very nice and cozy atmosphere in the restaurant."

"Definitely a go-to spot for great Italian food and service if you’re in the area. Mama Mia’s has World Famous garlic bread, and its no debate. For an appetizer, two of us split the dinner salad and you get free garlic bread with it. FYI they sell their Italian dressing in pints and quarts to-go, make sure to store it in your cabinet or on the counter. We also ordered more garlic bread for the table. Pizza was phenomenal, highly recommend the sausage. For Root Beer fans they do have Sprecher but it’s not on the menu. For the ladies who like a fruity and sweet alcoholic drink, no questions make sure to get the red moscato. Note: They don’t take reservations, we went on a Friday around 6:30 and the restaurant wait time was probably 10 minutes. Service was the best from start to finish. They wrap all of your left overs for you. You will feel at home with any waitress you get. Definitely add Mama Mia’s to your list and next time out. (I’ll add a pic of the salad on my next trip)"

"I went to Mama Mia’s, and it is still as good as I remembered it to be. I haven’t been in over a decade. They believe in keeping a good thing going. The waitress was very friendly, and we had immediate seating on an early Friday evening. We ordered the chicken fettuccine, large cheese, sausage and pepperoni pizza that had the most perfect thin crust and house salads. Everything was incredibly delicious to me. Oh did I forget to mention that I got a piece of their world famous garlic bread. It’s still good! We were treated so nicely by our waitress. She was so incredibly attentive. I believe we left her at least a 50% tip. I will most certainly be back."